This bibliography is compiled for use by the Illinois Domestic Violence
/ Substance Abuse Multidisciplinary Task Force. Comments and additions
should be sent to Larry Bennett
O'Farrell, Timothy J; Murphy, Christopher M. (2002). Behavioral couples
therapy for alcoholism and drug abuse: Encountering the problem of domestic
violence. Wekerle, Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed). The
violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance
abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 293-303). New York, NY, US:
Brunner-Routledge. xii, 376pp.
Describes and clarifies the role of behavioral couples therapy (BCT)
in treating partner violence among men seeking treatment for alcoholism
and drug abuse, as well as discusses general clinical issues in intervention
for intimate violence and addiction problems. Treatment methods and results
from outcome studies of BCT are discussed. The chapter also discusses BCT
and partner violence, how partner violence is handled in BCT with alcoholic
and drug-abusing patients, and gives cautions and clarifications about
BCT and partner violence in the treatment of substance-abusing patients.
The chapter concludes with a plea for reliance on evidence rather than
ideology to guide interventions for the combined problems of intimate violence
and addiction so that best practices may be consonant with evidence-based
therapy.
Leonard, Kenneth E. (2002). Alcohol and substance abuse in marital
violence and child maltreatment. Wekerle, Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie
(Ed). (2002). The violence
and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance abuse
and relationship violence. (pp. 194-219). New York, NY, US: Brunner-Routledge.
Discusses the following topics(1) developmental issues in alcohol use
across the early adult years, (2) developmental issues in marital and parental
violence, (3) developmental challenges and the alcohol-family violence
relationship, (4) the alcohol-marital violence relationship (including
its moderators and acute alcohol effects), and (5) the alcohol-child abuse
and child neglect relationship (including its moderators and acute alcohol
effects). A review of the research literature emphasizes that acute and
chronic alcohol use play important roles in violence for certain people
under certain circumstances. The author suggests that while the research
has tended to neglect developmental aspects, the relationship between alcohol
and family violence may differ importantly across developmental epochs.
The author emphasizes that while violent behavior clearly has roots in
childhood, the developmental transitions to adolescence, early adulthood,
and parenthood provide contextual shifts in which this behavior may be
altered.
Crittenden, Patricia McKinsey; Claussen, Angelika Hartl. (2002).
Developmental psychopathology perspectives on substance abuse and relationship
violence. Wekerle, Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed). (2002). The
violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance
abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 44-63). New York, NY, US:
Brunner-Routledge.
This chapter is concerned with the developmental pathways that increase
the probability of drug use, relationship violence, and the co-occurence
of these conditions. Two central ideas form the underlying structure of
this chapter. The first is the assumption that, in most cases, risk for
maladaptation and maladaptation itself are not random events, but rather
follow a series of developmental experiences that increase the probability
of specific risk outcomes. The second is that both substance abuse and
relationship violence can be considered strategies for resolving problems.
The question becomes why some individuals select these strategies, while
others do not. The chapter begins with a review of research on the antecedents
and correlates of (1) substance abuse and (2) interpersonal violence, and
their effects on development. Both discussions include a brief overview
of theories regarding each. Then, a theoretical model for describing context-adapted
coping strategies, together with predisposing developmental conditions,
is presented. The authors conclude by linking the empirical evidence to
these strategies to suggest several developmental pathways that carry risk
for substance abuse and interpersonal violence.
Wekerle, Christine; Wall, Anne-Marie. (2002). Introduction: The overlap
between relationship violence and substance abuse. Wekerle, Christine (Ed);
Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed). The
violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance
abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 1-21). New York, NY, US: Brunner-Routledge.
xii, 376pp.
Examines the extent to which alcohol and drug use, abuse, and dependence
coexist with violence among intimates. First, the overlap between child
abuse and parental substance use and abuse is presented, followed by a
discussion of the contribution of child abuse to adult addiction. Next,
the role of alcohol and drugs in domestic violence is examined. It is concluded
that the prevalence of the overlap between substance abuse and relationship
violence is generally high, and that this is most evident in high-risk
samples (i.e., those that are positive on either relationship violence
or substance abuse). The authors note that the specific estimate of the
prevalence of this overlap depends on many factors, including definitional
criteria (i.e., diagnostic, legal), sampling procedures (i.e., self-referred,
court-ordered), data-gathering method (i.e., interview, questionnaire),
and information source (i.e., parent, partner, child, professional). Other
conclusions and directions for future work are considered.
Wekerle, Christine & Wall, Anne-Marie (2002).
The violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in
substance abuse and relationship violence. New York, NY, US: Brunner-Routledge.
Attempts to document the dual problem of relationship violence and
addictions, as well as examine estimates of their overlap across the lifespan
and subpopulations. The editors note that in varying degrees, the weight
of the data point to the overlap among child maltreatment, partner violence,
alcohol abuse, illicit drug abuse, and polysubstance abuse. A main goal
for this volume is to direct scholarly attention to theoretical frameworks
that could guide understanding and inform the development of dual-focused
prevention and treatment programs. A second goal is to address these overlapping
problems at different stages across the lifespan, from adolescence to older
adulthood. Finally, attention to the clinical reality for the dual problem
of relationship violence and addition leads to an examination of prevention
and treatment efforts. In addition to discussing important issues for intervention,
this volume seeks to profile novel and promising prevention and treatment
approaches, and to present more established, empirically validated interventions.
Contextual questions such as cultural differences and access to treatment
are addressed, and conceptual models informing intervention are presented.
I. Theoretical frameworks
Biological bases of addiction and aggression in close relationships (Robert O. Pihl and Peter N. S. Hoaken)Developmental psychopathology perspectives on substance abuse and relationship violence (Patricia McKinsey Crittenden and Angelika Hartl Claussen)
Personality factors and substance abuse in relationship violence and child abuse: A review and theoretical analysis (Gordon L. Flett and Paul L. Hewitt)Substance abuse and co-occurring psychiatric disorders in victims of intimate violence (Sherry H. Stewart and Anne L. Israeli)Cognitive social learning models of substance use and intimate violence (Anne-Marie Wall and Sherry McKee)
II. Relationship violence and addiction across the lifespan
Bullying, sexual harassment, dating violence, and substance use among adolescents (Debra J. Pepler, Wendy M. Craig, Jennifer Connolly, and Kathryn Henderson) Sexual assault and relationship violence among college students: Examining the role of alcohol and other drugs (Mark D. Wood and Kenneth J. Sher) Alcohol and substance abuse in marital violence and child maltreatment (Kenneth E. Leonard) Substance abuse and interpersonal violence in older adults (Mandra L. Rasmussen Hall and Victoria M. Follette)
III. Clinical issues in intervention for intimate violence and addiction problems
Violence and alcohol: Cultural issues and barriers to treatment (John Schafer and Raul Caetano) Treating dual problems of partner violence and substance abuse (William R. Downs and Brenda A. Miller) Treating the addicted male batterer: Promising directions for dual-focused programming (Caroline Easton and Rajita Sinha) Behavioral couples therapy for alcoholism and drug abuse: Encountering the problem of domestic violence (Timothy J. O'Farrell and Christopher M. Murphy) Bridging the gap: Prevention of adolescent risk behaviors and development of healthy nonviolent dating relationships (Anna-Lee Pittman and David A. Wolfe)
Conclusion: Clinical and research issues in relationship violence and
substance abuse (Christine Wekerle and Anne-Marie Wall)
De Bellis, Michael D. (2002). Developmental traumatology: A contributory
mechanism for alcohol and substance use disorders.
Psychoneuroendocrinology. 27(1-2), 155-170.
Early childhood traumatic experiences, such as childhood maltreatment,
are associated with an enhanced risk of adolescent and adult alcohol and
substance use disorders (defined as Mental Disorders-IV (DSM-IV) alcohol
or substance abuse or dependence). Maltreated children and adolescents
manifest dysregulation of major biological stress response systems including
adverse influences on brain development. Dysregulation of biological stress
response systems may lead to an enhanced vulnerability for psychopathology,
particularly posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression. These
negative affect disorders may put a child at increased risk for adolescent
or young adult onset alcohol or substance use disorders. Thus, studies
in developmental traumatology may prove to be critical in the effort to
attempt to link the neurobiology of maltreatment-related PTSD with the
neurobiology of alcohol and substance use disorders and in developing early
strategies for the prevention of adolescent and adult alcohol and substance
use disorders.
Testa, Maria; Leonard, Kenneth E. (2001). The impact of husband physical
aggression and alcohol use on marital functioning: Does alcohol "excuse"
the violence? Violence & Victims,
16(5), 507-516.
Replicated and extended a study which suggested that wives hold husbands
less responsible for their aggressive behavior when husbands are problem
drinkers (J. Katz et al, 1995). The independent and interactive effects
of husband physical aggression and husband alcohol use on wives' marital
satisfaction and thoughts of divorce were examined among newlywed couples.
Data were collected on husband alcohol use over the past year, wives' marital
adjustment, husbands' marital aggression, and wives' thoughts of divorce.
There were a total of 387 participants. Husband physical aggression had
a significant negative effect on marital satisfaction and a significant
positive effect on divorce ideation regardless of the measure of husband
alcohol use employed. Alcohol dependence had a negative effect on satisfaction;
however, in no case was there an interaction between alcohol and aggression.
Results fail to replicate an earlier study supporting an excuse function
of alcohol and suggest that alcohol does not mitigate the negative effects
of domestic violence on marital functioning.
Chartas, Nicole D; Culbreth, John R. (2001). Counselor treatment
of coexisting domestic violence and substance abuse: A qualitative study.
Journal of Addictions & Offender Counseling. Vol 22(1), 2-11.
This study explored the philosophical issues hindering the linkage
of substance abuse and domestic violence treatment. Results suggest that
counselors tend to use treatment models that could not concurrently assign
responsibility and address either present or past victimization.
Coker, Ann L; Smith, Paige Hall; McKeown, Robert E; King, Melissa
J. (2000). Frequency and correlates of intimate partner violence by type:
Physical, sexual, and psychological battering. American
Journal of Public Health. Vol 90(4), 553-559.
Examined frequency and correlates of intimate partner violence, including
physical and sexual abuse, battering, and perceived emotional abuse, among
females seeking primary health care. 1,401 females (aged 18-65 yrs) attending
family practice clinics completed an in-clinic survey assessing intimate
partner violence. Results show that 55.1% of Ss had experienced some type
of intimate partner violence in a current, most recent, or past intimate
relationship with a male partner. 20.2% were currently experiencing intimate
partner violence. Among those who had experienced partner violence in any
relationship, 77.3% experienced physical or sexual violence, and 22.7%
experienced nonphysical abuse. Alcohol or drug abuse by the male partner
was the strongest correlate of violence. It is concluded that partner substance
abuse and intimate partner violence in the family of origin were strong
risk factors for experiencing violence.
Schafer, John; Caetano, Raul. (2002). Violence and alcohol: Cultural
issues and barriers to treatment. Wekerle, Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie
(Ed). (2002). The violence
and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance abuse
and relationship violence. (pp. 239-253). New York, NY, US: Brunner-Routledge.
Notes that access to health care in the US is a function of many variables,
including income, education, health insurance coverage (HIC), and ethnicity.
This chapter briefly discusses the barriers associated with access to HIC
and how this gateway to health care is associated with alcohol consumption
and intimate partner violence (IPV). Specifically, the chapter examines
the empirical data on HIC for treatment for IPV and alcoholism among ethnic
Americans. An analysis of the 1995 Couples Study, comprising a total of
1,599 Black, Hispanic, White, and mixed ethnicity (in which the ethnicities
of the partners did not match) heterosexual couples, is presented. Ss were
interviewed about their demographic characteristics, alcohol consumption
patterns, HIC, and the occurrence of 11 IPV behaviors. Results suggest
that barriers to minority health care exist and are particularly prevalent
among US Hispanics. Income was the most important factor in determining
HIC status. Results suggest that minority couples who are affected by alcohol
problems, including alcohol-related IPV, will be less likely to find the
appropriate care to solve their problems. It is suggested that the inequality
in access to care is likely to further contribute to the disparity in IPV
across ethnic groups.
Caetano, Raul; Nelson, Scott; Cunradi, C. (2001). Intimate partner
violence, dependence symptoms and social consequences from drinking among
White, Black and Hispanic couples in the United States. American
Journal on Addictions. Vol 10(Suppl) 2001, 60-69.
Examined the relationship between intimate partner violence (IPV),
alcohol dependence symptoms, and drinking-drug use social consequences
among White, Black, and Hispanic couples. 1,440 couples (aged 18+ yrs)
completed interviews concerning sociodemographic characteristics, psychological-psychosocial
aggression attitudes, IPV, alcohol consumption, alcohol problems, and drug
use. Results show that Ss who reported alcohol dependence symptoms or social
consequences from drinking were more likely to inflict IPV. IPV rates were
affected by social consequences from drinking for Whites and Blacks, and
were associated more with problems of male Ss than female Ss. Alcohol dependence
among Blacks was strongly associated with IPV, and Blacks were more associated
with IPV independent of problem type. Findings suggest that involvement
in a violent relationship is part of a problem behavior syndrome among
Blacks more than any other ethnic group. It is concluded that predictors
of IPV vary by ethnicity.
Chermack, Stephen T; Fuller, Bret E; Blow, Frederic C. (2000). Predictors
of expressed partner and non-partner violence among patients in substance
abuse treatment. Drug &
Alcohol Dependence. Vol 58(1-2) Feb 2000, 43-54.
Explored the extent and nature of expressed violence in both partner
and non-partner relationships, presents descriptive information regarding
factors associated with violence severity, and examined with Structural
Equation Modeling (SEM) the interrelationships among potential predictor
variables (age, gender, minority status, SES and alcohol and drug problem
severity) in relation to partner and non-partner violence. This study examined
reports of expressed partner and non-partner violence among 126 men and
126 women (aged 18-73 yrs) in the 12 mo prior to substance abuse treatment.
Rates of violence were 57% for partner, 53% for non-partner, and 75% collapsing
across partner and non-partner relationships. Partner violence was predicted
by age, marital status, and drug problem severity. Non-partner violence
was predicted by gender, income, alcohol and drug problem severity. It
is concluded that results highlight that individuals in substance abuse
treatment are at high risk for violence, and targeted screening and intervention
approaches should be routine in addictions treatment.
Suman, L.. N; Nagalakshmi, S. V. (1996). Family dysfunction in alcoholic
families. Indian Journal
of Clinical Psychology. Vol 23(2) Sep 1996, 117-121.
Examined the variables that influence the degree of family dysfunction
in alcoholic families. 40 alochol dependent men (mean age 39.40 yrs) and
their spouses (mean age 32.55 yrs) were administered a semi structured
interview schedule, the Interpersonal Checklist, the Eysenck Personality
Questionnaire and Family Interaction Scales. Data were analyzed using stepwise
multiple regression analysis. Results indicate that 8 variables significantly
influenced family functioning: emotional problems in the children, discrepancy
between spouse's perception of the alcoholic and spouse's perception of
ideal spouse on the Dominance dimension, role functioning of the alocholic,
Psychoticism scores of the alcoholic, discrepancy between alcoholic's perception
of self and spouse's perception of the alcoholic on the Love dimension,
Neuroticism scores of the spouses, discrepancy between alcoholic's perception
of self and spouse's perception of ideal spouse on the Dominance dimension,
and spouse abuse by the alcoholic.
Smith, James W. (2000). Addiction medicine and domestic violence. Journal
of Substance Abuse Treatment. Vol 19(4), 329-338.
Discusses characteristics of a domestic violence relationship and appropriate
action by addiction medicine practitioners. Typical strategies that allow
the abuser to establish power and control over his partner include isolating
the victim, physical and psychological battering, and sexual abuse. These
strategies are not used continuously. Instead, violent behavior generally
follows a cyclic pattern consisting of the 3 phases of the explosive phase,
the honeymoon phase, and the tension-building phase. Because alcohol and
other drug dependencies are frequently found in both the perpetrators and
victims of violence, addiction medicine practitioners have a unique opportunity
to intervene in these life-threatening disorders. Guidelines for dealing
with the victims of domestic violence in the addiction medicine patient
population include asking victims direct questions about battering in a
private interview, assessing safety by listening to patients' stories,
providing referrals or information about resources, arranging follow-up
visits, and documenting information in patients' charts. The appropriate
timing of intervention can facilitate treatment for addiction and domestic
violence.
Hirschel, David; Hutchison, Ira W. (2001). The relative effects of
offense, offender and victim variables on the decision to prosecute domestic
violence cases. Violence
Against Women. Vol 7(1), 46-59.
Traditionally, even when the police have arrested suspected spouse
abusers, prosecutors have been reluctant to follow through with prosecution.
Using a sample of 424 cases in which abusers were either arrested on the
scene or issued citations for court appearance, this research study investigates
whether characteristics surrounding the offense (such as cause of the argument
and victim injury), offender characteristics (such as prior record and
substance abuse), or victim characteristics (such as relationship with
the offender and substance abuse) most impact the prosecution's decision
to prosecute. The policy implications of the findings also are discussed.
Markward, Martha; Dozier, Cheryl; Hooks, Kirk; Markward, Nathan.
(2000). Culture and the intergenerational transmission of substance abuse,
women abuse, and child abuse: A diathesis-stress perspective. Children
& Youth Services Review. Vol 22(3-4), 237-250.
This manuscript focuses on culture as moderating the transmission of
substance abuse and spouse abuse to impact child well-being in families
across generations. Within the context of a diathesis-stress model, the
authors propose that it is the interaction between particular internal
factors, such as biochemical, genetic, and/or psychosocial factors, and
external factors that is critical in understanding intergenerational transmission.
Based on a review of related literature, the authors suggest a nonlinear
dynamic perspective on intergenerational transmission that maintains a
presumption of cultural and ethnic "environment" distinctly interacting
with genetics and physiology to produce self-reinforcing behaviors that
may be passed from one generation to another.
Easton, Caroline J; Swan, Suzanne; Sinha, Rajita. (2000). Prevalence
of family violence in clients entering substance abuse treatment. Journal
of Substance Abuse Treatment. Vol 18(1), 23-28.
Evaluated 105 clients who were assessed for substance-related problems
and a history of domestic violence. A brief survey on family violence examined
whether clients were adult victims, childhood victims, and/or perpetrators
of physical violence. Results indicated that 37% of the sample reported
that they experienced a family history of physical violence. A total of
22% reported being an adult victim of physical violence, 14% reported being
a victim of childhood abuse, and 18% reported being a perpetrator of physical
violence. Results showed that substance-using clients with a history of
family violence (SAFV+) tended to have more individual therapy sessions
attended than substance-using clients without a history of family violence
(SAFV-). The SAFV+ group was different from the SAFV- group in that they
had significantly higher scores on the Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test
and the Beck Depression Inventory. The SAFV+ group also had more positive
urine screens for cocaine use within the 2-mo monitoring period. Findings
indicate the importance of assessing family history of violence in substance
abusers entering treatment, as this may have significant implications for
treatment outcome.
Leonard, Kenneth E. (1999). Alcohol use and husband marital aggression
among newlywed couples. In Arriaga, Ximena B. (Ed); Oskamp, Stuart (Ed). Violence
in intimate relationships. (pp. 113-135). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
This chapter addresses the role of alcoholism among domestically violent
men. The authors initiated the Buffalo Newlywed Study (BNS) to determine
the extent that both alcohol consumption (frequency of intoxication, average
daily alcohol consumption) and alcohol abuse (excessive consumption and
the occurrence of problems associated with consumption) are significantly
related to marital aggression. The BNS is a three-wave longitudinal study
of 647 newly married couples (aged 18-29) conducted over the first three
years of marriage. The core questionnaires focused on four general domains:
Alcohol consumption patterns, alcohol expectancies, personality factors,
and relationship functioning factors. The results of this research are
consistent with the hypothesis that alcohol has a role in the occurrence
of domestic violence among newly married couples. In addition, the presence
of alcohol, particularly among husbands, is associated with the occurrence
of physical rather than verbal aggression. While alcohol plays a role in
marital aggression, this role should not be overstated. Alcohol is neither
a necessary nor a sufficient cause of marital aggression.
Gehrenbeck-Shim, Anne R. (1998). The effects of physical and sexual
abuse on treatment outcome among substance abusers. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
59(3-B), 1366, US: Univ. Microfilms International.
Previous literature has shown links between abuse experiences and substance
use problems. Substance abuse is theorized as a form of self-medication
for painful affects following traumatic abuse experiences. The paucity
of prospective studies addressing treatment course for substance abusers
who have abuse histories has necessitated research in this area. The purpose
of this study was to explore whether substance abusers who report histories
of physical and/or sexual abuse have more severe psychopathology and poorer
treatment outcomes. The design consisted of interviews and questionnaires
administered to male and female patients entering substance abuse treatment
at Roger Williams Hospital. Follow-up interviews and questionnaires were
administered at one-, two- and three-month intervals. The interview instrument
assessed levels of substance use and treatment utilization. Questionnaires
assessed the presence of a reported physical and/or sexual abuse history
and levels of psychiatric symptomatology. The results replicate other studies
which have shown that, among a substance abuse population, there is a high
prevalence of patients reporting abuse histories. Statistical analyses
revealed significant relationships between reported abuse histories during
childhood and greater initial levels of psychopathology. Childhood physical
abuse resulted in the greatest degree of elevated psychiatric symptomatology
(depression, anxiety, PTSD symptoms, dissociation, and general psychiatric
distress). Childhood sexual abuse also resulted in elevated levels of trauma
symptomatology, dissociation, and psychiatric distress. Tests of the relationship
between the outcome variables (substance relapse and treatment utilization)
and abuse history were not significant. No relationship was shown between
the presence of an abuse history and greater likelihood of substance relapse
within the first three months of treatment or lesser likelihood to engage
in recommended treatment activities. Additional analyses were conducted
to ascertain whether patients who discontinued participation in the study
differed significantly from those who continued. Dropout/follow-up was
not related to demographics or abuse history. Whereas there were highly
significant relationships between childhood abuse and almost every measure
of psychopathology, there were no significant relationships found between
childhood abuse and the two outcome measures. These findings and recent
studies suggest the need for future research incorporating the independent
variables of abuse history, psychopathology, and specific drug of choice
in the prediction of treatment outcome.
Waldorf, Virginia Ann. (1998). The relationship between neuropsychological
deficits and spouse abuse: An examination of both abuser and victim. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
58(10-B), 5660.
Attempts to characterize the men and women involved in domestically
violent relationships have yielded mixed results across a wide range of
variables. These have included personality styles, violence in the family
of origin, and a history of substance abuse. What has been lacking in the
research to date is a thorough exploration of the neuropsychological characteristics
of these individuals. The present study was designed to test certain neurocognitive
functions using neuropsychological assessment in both the males and females
currently involved in a violent relationship. In Phase I of the study,
163 individuals from domestically violent couples, 83 women and 80 men,
were assessed on certain neuropsychological variables. These included measures
of cognitive flexibility, verbal proficiency, empathic capacity, effective
planning, and impulse control. A multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA)
was used to determine how these variables correlated with other variables
considered to be common in this population. Phase II of the research explored
how effective the use of these neurocognitive variables would be in differentiating
between two matched groups of maritally discordant men and women. Twenty-one
individuals from violent relationships were matched on the variables of
age, education, ethnicity, and marital status with 21 individuals from
maritally discordant, but nonviolent relationships. A MANOVA was used first
to determine whether these two groups could be discriminated using the
predictor variables found discriminative in earlier work, and secondly,
to determine if these groups could be discriminated on the basis of the
neurocognitive variables. Results from Phase I indicated that only the
verbal proficiency variable was significantly correlated with certain personality
styles. Additionally, and as predicted, no significant gender difference
was found on the neurocognitive variables within the domestically violent
group. On all neuropsychological variables the men and women performed
comparably. Results from Phase II indicated that these same tests of verbal
proficiency were significantly discriminative between the violent and nonviolent
groups (F (1,39) = 5.25, p<.01). There also was a significant group
difference on one measure of impulse control (F (1,39) = 6.53, p<.05).
Significance of findings, limitations of research, and treatment implications
were discussed.
Kunitz, Stephen J; Levy, Jerrold E; McCloskey, Joanne; Gabriel, K.
Ruben. (1998). Alcohol dependence and domestic violence as sequelae of
abuse and conduct disorder in childhood. Child
Abuse & Neglect. Vol 22(11), 1079-1091.
Examined (1) the importance of childhood abuse as a risk factor for
conduct disorder; (2) the importance of each form of abuse and conduct
disorder as risk factors for alcohol dependence; and (3) the relative importance
of each form of abuse, conduct disorder, and alcohol dependence as risk
factors for being a perpetrator and/or victim of domestic violence in the
Navajo population. Cases between the ages of 21 and 65 were interviewed
in alcohol treatment program and matched to community controls (alcohol
dependent and nonalcohol dependent). When adjusted for stratification by
age, community of residence, and sex, the combined control groups comprise
a representative sample of the Navajo male and female population 21-65
yrs of age. The prevalence of physical and sexual abuse before age 15 is
within limits observed in other populations. Each form of abuse is a risk
factor for conduct disorder. Along with conduct disorder, physical abuse
is a risk factor for alcohol dependence. Physical abuse and alcohol dependence
are independent risk factors for being involved in domestic violence as
both perpetrator and victim. There is suggestive evidence that domestic
violence has become more common.
Weiss, Michael J. Salomon; Wagner, Sheldon H. (1998). What explains
the negative consequences of adverse childhood experiences on adult health?
Insights from cognitive and neuroscience research. American
Journal of Preventive Medicine. Vol 14(4), 356-360.
Expands on the article by V. J. Felitti et al (see record 1998-04002-001)
on the effects of adverse childhood experiences on adult risk behavior,
health status, and disease by discussing results from cognitive and neuroscience
research. Felitti's results would be of little surprise to cognitive and
neuroscience researchers in that they are consistent with a vast confluence
of data from studies of CNS plasticity (the study of CNS organization as
a function of experience). Weiss and Wagner describe the neuron as a self-organizing
system, plasticity and CNS organization, the endurance of brain plasticity
through adulthood, and behavioral correlates to CNS plasticity, including
infant auditory perception, the effects of early intervention on intellectual
and academic achievement, and language acquisition.
Collins, James J; Kroutil, Larry A; Roland, E. Joyce; Moore-Gurrera,
Marlee. (1997). Issues in the linkages of alcohol and domestic violence
services. Galanter, Marc (Ed).
Recent developments in alcoholism, Vol. 13: Alcohol and violence: Epidemiology,
neurobiology, psychology, family issues. Recent developments in
alcoholism, Vol. 13. (pp. 387-405). New York, NY, US: Plenum Press.
Discuss the role of substance abuse in domestic violence and the implications
that the association between substance abuse and domestic violence have
for programs that deal with these problems / there are good reasons to
think that a substance abuse-domestic violence program service linkage
would be beneficial to clients / such linkage is infrequent, however, and
there are significant impediments to linkage / addresses these issues based
on a review of the literature in the substance abuse and domestic violence
fields and on interviews conducted with service providers in these fields
models for service linkage.
Galanter, Marc (Ed). (1997). Recent
developments in alcoholism, Vol. 13: Alcohol and violence: Epidemiology,
neurobiology, psychology, family issues. [Book Series Title: Recent developments
in alcoholism], Vol. 13. New York, NY, US: Plenum Press.
It is both appropriate and timely that this volume of "Recent Developments
in Alcoholism" is devoted to alcohol and violence, since violence is regarded
by many as the most important problem facing our society today. At this
point in time, it appears that alcohol is one of several factors leading
to violence. The other types of factors contributing to aggression appear
to be biochemical, genetic, psychological, and environmental in nature.
Other sections of this volume discuss these factors. Another key question
is how does the mix of all these factors increase aggression in some individuals
but not in others? The public health model may be useful in answering this
question. The premise of the public health model is that alcohol-related
problems arise from an interaction of individual (host) variables, alcohol
(agent), and environmental factors.
Dunnegan, Shelly Wolf. (1997). Violence, trauma and substance abuse. Journal
of Psychoactive Drugs. Vol 29(4), 345-351.
A review of the relevant literature concerning posttraumatic stress
disorder (PTSD), violence, and domestic violence suggests that violent
behavior, trauma, and substance abuse have a substantial connection; it
also suggests that shame is a powerful agent for rage. Shame permeates
many levels of society: the individual, the family, institutions and the
community. The policies of the criminal justice system are directed toward
promoting more shame in a population that has been saturated with shame
in the many levels of the culture. Attention is focused on the role of
alcohol and other drug use in the cycle of violence. Violent behavior,
violent individuals, and victims of violence are deeply affected emotionally,
physically, politically, and spiritually by drug use. This suggests that
any program designed to promote healing violent behavior, for victims and/or
perpetrators, should include attention to each of these spheres. The author
describes a program developed in the San Francisco City and County Jails
that includes a stress reduction group, a personal writing group, a partner
abuse group, and an anger and conflict management Group. The milieu is
described, as well as the components, methods and rationale for each group.
Irons, Richard; Schneider, Jennifer P. (1997). When is domestic violence
a hidden face of addiction? Journal
of Psychoactive Drugs. Vol 29(4) Oct-Dec 1997, 337-344.
This article reviews studies that address the comorbidity of domestic
violence, addictive disorders, and sexual abuse, and presents a model in
which domestic violence parallels the chief features of chemical dependency.
Domestic violence and addictive disorders share a number of behavioral
features, including loss of control, continuation of behavior despite adverse
consequences, preoccupation or obsession, development of tolerance, and
family involvement. Domestic violence predisposes the next generation to
both domestic violence and addictive disorders Sexual abuse within the
family of origin and/or the couple relationship is a common feature of
both domestic violence and substance addiction, and predisposes to both
disorders in the next generation. Clinicians encountering patients who
are perpetrators or victims of domestic violence or sexual trauma, or have
addictive disorders, must assess for the presence of comorbid problems.
Fischbach, Ruth L; Herbert, Barbara. (1997). Domestic violence and
mental health: Correlates and conundrums within and across cultures. Social
Science & Medicine. Vol 45(8) 1161-1176.
Discusses domestic violence in developing countries and examines the
impact on the mental health of victims. Accruing data reveal strengthening
associations between spouse abuse and depression, stress-related syndromes,
chemical dependency and substance abuse, and suicide. Documentation reveals
domestic violence to be endemic and to represent a significant cause of
physical morbidity and mortality to women in virtually every culture. Historically,
the human rights community has failed to recognize these violations against
women's rights. Brief narratives illustrate 3 common forms of violence:
marital rape, dowry-related deaths, and disproportionate exposure to HIV/AIDS.
Emerging social, legal, medical, and educational strategies, often culture
specific, offer novel local models to promote social change, beginning
with raising the status of women.
Brookoff, Daniel; O'Brien, Kimberly; Cook, Charles S; Thompson, Terry
D; Williams, Charles. (1997). Characteristics of participants in domestic
violence. Journal of the
American Medical Association. Vol 277(17), 1369-1373.
Surveyed 64 assailants and 72 victims at the scenes of domestic violence
as to circumstances of the assault, history of domestic violence, previous
arrests, use of antipsychotic medications, and previous use of health care
facilities and shelters as a result of domestic violence. Assessing families
in their homes allowed the identification of the involvement of children,
either as witnesses (85% of the cases) or as victims (15%), and the identification
of barriers to seeking help (e.g., fear of exacerbating the violence, strong
emotional and economic bonds with the perpetrator). Many of the perpetrators
were habitual substance abusers, and two thirds of the perpetrators had
used the combination of cocaine and ethanol on the day of the assault.
Lindquist, Carol U; Sass, Lillian E; Bottomley, Denise; Katin, Suzanne
M; et al. (1997). Should abused women's reports of partner substance abuse
be accepted as valid? Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 12(1) Mar 1997, 75-83.
Current research suggests that a husband's substance abuse is correlated
with severity of physical abuse and the woman's decision to leave a violent
situation. Often, only the battered woman's report of abuse is available.
This study compares women's reports of their partners' substance use/abuse
with their partners' report using a brief measure of polydrug and alcohol
abuse, the Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory (SASSI) and the Conflict
Tactics Scale (CTS). Data were analyzed for 25 recovery couples and 25
nonrecovery couples. The correlations for all 50 couples between the male's
reported use and the female's report of her partner's use on the SASSI
and the CTS were significant on all but one of the CTS scales (physical
violence). This suggests that the SASSI and possibly the CTS could be used
as valuable tools for assessing women's reports of their partner's substance
use/abuse.
Irons, Richard R. (1996). Comorbidity between violence and addictive
disease. Sexual Addiction
& Compulsivity. Vol 3(2), 85-96.
The single most significant cause of injury to women in the United
States is battery by someone with whom they have had an intimate relationship.
In many cases, substance-related disorders are at play. But the relationship
of substance abuse and violent behavior is not simply one of cause and
effect. Addictive sexual disorders are also associated with domestic violence,
which may start as pressure to submit to unwanted sexual play. Sex may
deteriorate into hostile or repressive activity, with abused partners participating
to avoid physical violence. A common barrier to treatment of sexual addiction
is the perpetrator's fear of exposure. Another complicating factor is the
clinician's countertransference. Helping professionals would do well to
develop clinical plans for approaching both victims and perpetrators. This
should include taking a thorough history, having literature on hand about
available resources, obtaining informed consent, documenting the trauma,
and considering the consequences of whatever actions are taken.
Windle, Michael; Windle, Rebecca C; Scheidt, Douglas M; Miller, Gregory
B. (1995). Physical and sexual abuse and associated mental disorders among
alcoholic inpatients. American
Journal of Psychiatry. Vol 152(9), 1322-1328.
Investigated the adult psychiatric correlates of childhood abuse among
481 male and 321 female alcoholic inpatients (aged 19-57 yrs). Prevalence
of reported childhood abuse was 59% for women and 30% for men. Family history
of alcoholism was associated with higher levels of physical and sexual
abuse. 49% of women and 12% of men reported sexual abuse (with or without
physical abuse); 33% of women and 24% of men reported physical abuse (with
or without sexual abuse); and 23% of women and 5% of men reported dual
abuse. Abuse status, and especially dual abuse, was associated with higher
rates of antisocial personality disorder and suicide attempts among women
and men, with generalized anxiety disorder among women, and with major
depression among men.
Robins, Lee N. (1995). The epidemiology of aggression. Hollander,
Eric (Ed); Stein, Dan J. (Ed). Impulsivity
and aggression. (pp. 43-55). New York, NY: John Wiley & Sons
[discuss] aggression [and] note that violence is closely related to
conduct disorder, antisocial personality, and substance abuse / attempt
to estimate how large the problem of violence is, how substantial the evidence
is that it is increasing, in what parts of the population it appears most
frequently, and what its correlates are, in the hope that they may shed
light on the causes of its increase information from police and hospitals
and social agencies [assault, child abuse] / survey data in general populations
[victims, domestic violence, fighting]
O'Farrell, Timothy; Murphy, Christopher M. (1995). Marital violence
before and after alcoholism treatment. Journal
of Consulting & Clinical Psychology. Vol 63(2), 256-262.
The prevalence and frequency of marital violence were assessed for
88 male alcoholics and their wives at entry to and 1 year after completing
a behavioral marital therapy (BMT) program. In the year before BMT, both
the alcoholics and their wives had a significantly and substantially higher
prevalence and frequency of marital violence than reported by a demographically
matched, nonalcoholic comparison sample. Although violence decreased significantly
in prevalence and frequency in the year after BMT it remained significantly
elevated relative to the matched controls when the entire sample of alcoholics
was considered. However, extent of violence after BMT was significantly
associated with the alcoholics' drinking outcome status: After treatment,
remitted alcoholics no longer had elevated marital violence levels whereas
relapsed alcoholics did. Implications for understanding the marital violence
and alcoholism connection and cautions that should be exercised in interpreting
the results are discussed.
Conner, Kenneth R; Ackerly, Gary D. (1994). Alcohol-related battering:
Developing treatment strategies. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 9(2), 143-155.
Explored the relationship between alcohol and battering to develop
appropriate intervention strategies. Studies demonstrating a correlation
between alcohol and battering are reviewed, and the intoxicated aggression
literature is summarized using K. Graham's (see record 1981-23587-001)
conceptual system. It is tentatively concluded that the role of physiological
and cognitive changes brought on by alcohol, the interaction of alcohol
and frustration in producing aggression, and needs for personal power in
men who drink and then aggress are all promising explanations for the alcohol-battering
link. The applicability of disease model-based treatment for alcoholism,
cognitive-behavioral-based treatment for alcoholism and battering, and
feminist-based treatment for battering are each considered. A model for
incorporating an alcohol component to a batterer treatment program is introduced.
Bennett, Larry; Lawson, Marie. (1994). Barriers to cooperation between
domestic-violence and substance-abuse programs. Families
in Society. Vol 75(5), 277-286.
388 staff and administrators drawn from a statewide sample of 74 substance
abuse and domestic violence programs completed a questionnaire on linkage,
referral, impairments to interagency cooperation, and beliefs about cross-problem
incidence. Ss estimated that 46% of the male substance abusers currently
in their care were batterers, 60% of the female substance abusers were
victims, and 42% of the women currently in domestic violence programs were
substance abusers. 80% of Ss indicated that these clients would benefit
from increased cooperation between substance abuse and domestic violence
programs.
Cooley, Cynthia S; Severson, Kathleen. (1993). Establishing feminist
systemic criteria for viewing violence and alcoholism. Hansen, Marsali
(Ed); Harway, Michele (Ed). Battering and family therapy: A feminist perspective.
(pp. 217-226). Thousand Oaks, CA, US; Thousand Oaks, CA, US: Sage
(from the book) alcohol abuse and family violence have been linked
by many researchers / addresses the specific concerns of therapists who
may need to treat both problems simultaneously / discusses the difficulties
inherent in current theoretical formulations employed by popular approaches
to the treatment of drug and alcohol abuse and presents more useful conceptualizations,
including recommendations for treatment (from the chapter) present feminist
systemic criteria for viewing violence and alcoholism by exploring the
techniques of clearly naming violence, highlighting linguistic dilemmas
facing the alcoholism field, and challenging clients to leave the source
of violence
Kurtz, David S. (1993). Alcohol abuse as a predictor and correlate of domestic violence. Dissertation Abstracts International. Vol 53(7-B), Jan 1993, 3779.
Collins, James J; Messerschmidt, Pamela M. (1993). Epidemiology of
alcohol-related violence. Alcohol
Health & Research World. Vol 17(2), 93-100.
Reviews research on alcohol consumption as a contributor to interpersonal
criminal violence. Studies of the relationship between drinking and homicide/nonsexual
assault, sexual assault, domestic violence, and robbery are detailed. These
types of violence often involve drinking by the offender, the victim, or
both. It is suggested, however, that the relationship between alcohol use
and such behavior is complex, involving individual, situational, and sociocultural
influences.
O'Farrell, Timothy J; Choquette, Keith. (1991). Marital violence
in the year before and after spouse-involved alcoholism treatment. Family
Dynamics of Addiction Quarterly. Vol 1(1), 32-40.
Administered the Conflict Tactics Scales questionnaire on marital violence
to 29 alcoholics (aged 28-56 yrs) and their wives (aged 28-63 yrs) at entry
into and 1 yr after completing a behavioral marital therapy (BMT) treatment
program. In the year before BMT, both Ss and their wives had a significantly
higher and 5-6 times greater prevalence of any violent act, of minor to
moderate violent acts, and of severe violent acts than that reported by
a 1985 US national sample. In the year after BMT, husband-to-wife overall,
moderate, and severe violence decreased significantly in prevalence or
frequency. The prevalence of overall violence by Ss remained significantly
elevated relative to national norms, being still more than twice as prevalent
among Ss. Wife-to-husband violence after BMT was significantly decreased
in prevalence or frequency and no longer significantly elevated relative
to national norms for overall, moderate, and severe violence.
Miller, Brenda A. (1990).
The interrelationships between alcohol and drugs and family violence.
National Institute on Drug Abuse: Research Monograph Series. Research
Mono 103, 177-207.
Presents research findings from studies that explored the multidimensional
relationships between family violence and alcohol or drug problems. Three
forms of family violence were considered: child abuse, childhood sexual
abuse, and spousal violence. Studies were conducted using (1) 45 alcoholic
women in treatment and 40 women in the general population, and (2) 82 male
parolees and their spouses. Among the findings: (1) women alcoholics were
more likely than general population women to experience spousal violence;
(2) alcohol problems in women contributed to the level of spousal violence
women experienced; (3) experiences of child abuse were related to the development
of alcohol problems; and (4) childhood sexual abuse was related to the
development of alcohol problems in women.
Lowrance, N. Ann. (1990). Domestic violence. Engs, Ruth C. (Ed).
Alcohol & Drug Problems n. (1990). Women: Alcohol and other drugs.
(pp. 165-173). Dubuque, IA, US: Kendall/Hunt Publishing Company. xiv, 173pp.
(from the chapter) historically, family violence and chemical dependency
have been linked / while commonalities exist, available data does not support
the contention that substance abuse causes men or women to batter or that
family violence causes substance abuse / when substance use disorders and
domestic violence co-exist in the same family unit, both issues must be
addressed battered woman syndrome [stereotype images of family and male-female
relations, traumatic bonding, learned helplessness, fear, physical safety,
economic hardships, lack of support] / alcohol, drugs and spousal violence
Slater, Nancy A. (1990). Connections: An integrative literature analysis of publications examining the relationships among substance abuse, eating disorders, sexual abuse and physical abuse. Dissertation Abstracts International. Vol 50(8-B), Feb 1990, 3679
Stewart, Sherry H; Israeli, Anne L. (2002). Substance abuse and co-occurring
psychiatric disorders in victims of intimate violence. Wekerle, Christine
(Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed). The
violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance
abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 98-122). New York, NY, US:
Brunner-Routledge.
Explores the possible roles that a variety of psychological disorders
might play in the well-documented relation between violence exposure and
substance disorders in victims of familial violence. Three specific disorders
are focused upon: depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, and sexual
dysfunction. The authors first examine the mental health correlates of
exposure to familial childhood physical and sexual abuse, including both
psychiatric disorders and substance-related disorders. Included are studies
with adults using long-term retrospective methodologies, studies with adolescents
conducted closer in time to the childhood violence exposure, and a few
prospective, longitudinal studies. Studies concerning the mental health
correlates of partner-to-partner violence ("spousal battery"), including
both psychiatric and chemical use disorders, are reviewed next. The authors
explore specific mechanisms that may explain the higher rates of both certain
psychiatric disorders and of substance-related disorders among victims
of domestic violence, and review evidence regarding comorbidity and potential
function relations. Finally, a methodological critique of studies is provided
and suggestions are proposed for future research.
Flett, Gordon L; Hewitt, Paul L. (2002). Personality factors and
substance abuse in relationship violence and child abuse: A review and
theoretical analysis. Wekerle, Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed).
The violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in
substance abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 64-97). New York,
NY, US: Brunner-Routledge.
Selectively reviews existing reserach and theory on the role of personality
factors in domestic violence and child abuse, with a particular focus on
the associations among personality, substance abuse, and mistreatment of
significant others. The chapter begins with an overview of various models
and conceptualizations that focus on the role of personality factors in
relationship violence. Next, research on the role of personality factors
in relationship violence is reviewed, with the caveat that most of the
research has focused on domestic violence and relatively few of the reviewed
investigations examined the role of personality factors and substance abuse
in child maltreatment. The review concludes with an integrative model that
seeks to apply a diathesis-stress and coping approach to domestic violence
and child maltreatment.
Bergman, Bo; Brismar, Bo. (1993). Assailants and victims: A comparative
study of male wife-beaters and battered males. Journal
of Addictive Diseases. Vol 12(4) 1993, 1-10.
18 male wife-beaters were compared with 19 battered males concerning
their background, history of addiction, and present social situation, as
well as present violence. The 2 groups of males had a very similar background,
including violence in their parental home. Alcohol and drug problems were
common, the males generally belonged to the lower social classes, and the
number of divorcees was large. Many of the battered males had abused someone
and the male batterers had been victimized themselves. Results indicate
that the same background and precipitating factors will predestine the
male to be a batterer or to be battered, but most probably both.
Easton, Caroline; Sinha, Rajita. (2002). Treating the addicted
male batterer: Promising directions for dual-focused programming. Wekerle,
Christine (Ed); Wall, Anne-Marie (Ed). The
violence and addiction equation: Theoretical and clinical issues in substance
abuse and relationship violence. (pp. 275-292). New York, NY, US:
Brunner-Routledge.
Discusses several issues
in the treatment of co-occuring substance abuse and family violence problems.
The authors note that despite the overlap between substance abuse and domestic
violence, integrated treatment services for both violence problems and
substance abuse in batterers are rare. It is also noted that court-mandated
batterers account for the majority of clients attending battering programs,
and that this fact raises issues as to the batter's level of motivation
to change his behaviors with respect to internal vs external motivators.
The authors argue that it is necessary to understand who male batterers
are in terms of not only their violence and legal histories, but also with
regard to their psychiatric status, including substance abuse and dependence,
within the context of what brings the batterer to treatment. Specific topics
discussed include criminal justice issues affecting batterer interventions,
domestic violence legislation, diversion programs and conditions of probation,
treatment compliance and treatment outcomes, policies regarding substance
use at the time of an alleged offense, and treatment models for male batterers.
Umhau, John C; George,
David T; Reedd, Shawn; Petrulis, Sarah G; Rawlings, Robert; Porges, Stephen
W. (2002). Atypical autonomic regulation in perpetrators of violent domestic
abuse. Psychophysiology.
Vol 39(2) Mar 2002, 117-123.
Perpetrators of domestic
violence describe symptoms that are compatible with exaggerated autonomic
arousal at the domestic violence. This inappropriate arousal may be reflected
in altered heart rate regulation. If heart rate is systematically regulated
by vagal mechanisms, then increases in heart rate should correlate with
decreases in cardiac as indexed by respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA).
We hypothesized that perpetrators of domestic violence have an alteration
in heart rate regulation. To test this hypothesis we compared the results
of a postural shift on perpetrators, healthy volunteers, and nonviolent
alcoholics. Results showed there were no significant differences in heart
rate, RSA, or catecholamines. However, the significant inverse relationship
between posture-elicited changes in RSA and heart rate present in the healthy
volunteers was not found in perpetrators. These differences in the covariation
between heart rate and RSA may represent differences in the neural regulation
of heart rate and may be to difficulties in controlling autonomic state.
Johnson, Richard R. (2001).
Intensive probation for domestic violence offenders. Federal
Probation. 65(3), 36-39.
Discusses an intensive probation
program to supervise the rising number of the most serious domestic violence
offenders in Kane County, Illinois. Challenges discussed that led to development
of the Domestic Violence Officer probation program include motivating the
offender to change behavior not seen as wrong, return of the victim to
the offender in spousal abuse cases, substance abuse, and long patterns
of abuse by offenders. The program selects higher-risk domestic violence
offenders for specialized stricter supervision. The program involves a
requirement that all offenders complete a 26-wk domestic violence counseling
program, and if substance abuse is involved, special counseling can be
ordered. Early analysis of the program suggests that the program appears
successful at preserving community safety, holding offenders accountable,
and improving the non-violent coping skills of the offenders
Dalton, Bruce. (2001).
Batterer characteristics and treatment completion. Journal
of Interpersonal Violence, 16(12), 1223-1238.
Investigated the relationship
between completion of domestic violence treatment and the level of threat
or consequence perceived by a batterer from the referral source. 79 male
and 6 female batterers (aged 18-63 yrs) completed interviews concerning
substance abuse, arrest history, violence history, and perception of coercion
that Ss felt from the referral source. Results show that 20 Ss were unemployed
or employed part-time. Half the Ss had some indication of alcohol or drug
abuse symptoms. Most had a prior arrest record, and 22 had a prior arrest
for domestic violence. 87% reported partner violence within the past yr.
66% of Ss reported perceiving a high level of external coercion, and 18%
perceived a medium level of coercion. 71% of Ss completed treatment, but
the degree of threat from the referral source did not predict treatment
completion. Significant predictors of treatment completion were reported
symptoms of drug abuse and unemployment.
George, David T; Umhau,
John C; Phillips, Monte J; Emmela, Devadatham; Ragan, Paul W; Shoaf, Susan
E; Rawlings, Robert R. (2001). Serotonin, testosterone and alcohol in the
etiology of domestic violence.Psychiatry
Research. 104(1), 27-37.
Compared the cerebral spinal
fluid (CSF) concentrations of 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid (5-HIAA) and testosterone
obtained from perpetrators of domestic violence and a group of healthy
comparison Ss. Perpetrators with alcohol dependence (DV-ALC; n=13), perpetrators
without alcohol dependence (DV-NALC; n=10) and healthy comparison Ss (HCS;
n=20) were clinically assessed using the Spielberger Trait Anxiety, Brown-Goodwin
Aggression Scale, Buss Durkee Hostility Inventory and Straus Conflict Tactics.
Following an overnight fast and bed rest, Ss received a lumbar puncture
to obtain CSF concentrations of 5-HIAA and testosterone. Perpetrators scored
significantly higher on measures of aggression than HCS. DV-NALC had significantly
lower concentrations of CSF 5-HIAA and higher Straus Conflict Tactics (CT)
physical violence scores than DV-ALC and HCS. DV-ALC had significantly
higher concentrations of CSF testosterone than DV-NALC. DV-ALC also had
significantly higher Straus CT physical violence scores than HCS. DV-NALC
and DV-ALC differed on 5-HIAA concentrations, testosterone concentrations,
Straus CT physical violence scores and alcohol dependence. These results
suggest that DV-NALC and DV-ALC groups could have different biological
mechanisms mediating domestic violence.
Smith, Carol Lynn. (2001).
A potentially useful screening tool for domestic violence offenders derived
from the Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory-3 (SASSI-3).
Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering.
Vol 62(2-B), 1137.
Domestic violence exacts
a tremendous cost on individuals, families, and society. Victims pay in
many ways from the injuries suffered from physical violence to the trauma
of emotional and psychological abuse. The cost to society has been estimated
at $3 to $5 billion annually. Domestic violence offenders are not easily
identified by distinguishing characteristics. Often intervention for domestic
violence only occurs following an arrest and judicial directives to the
offender to undergo treatment for domestic violence, Since there are on
average nine violent incidents before a victim will call for police assistance,
the family will have already endured extensive negative effects. There
has been no screening tool for domestic violence offenders available for
treatment providers. The Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory-3 (SASSI-3)
is a widely used screening instrument for substance abuse. The SAS SI-3
was investigated to determine if it could also be used as a screening tool
for domestic violence offenders. This study compared 150 violent male offenders
to a self identified nonviolent control group of 75 men on the subtle items
of the SASSI-3 to determine if there would be significant differences between
the groups. The offender group scored higher on four sub-scales of the
SASSI-3 than the control group. One scale alone, the FAM scale was significantly
different between groups. Combined with the OAT, SAT, and SAM sub-scales,
the FAM scale was able to predict group membership with 78.7 percent accuracy.
Clinical implications and suggestion for future research are presented.
McBurnett, Keith; Kerckhoff,
Carl; Capasso, Lisa; Pfiffner, Linda J; Rathouz, Paul J; McCord, Mike;
Harris, Steven M. (2001). Antisocial personality, substance abuse, and
exposure to parental violence in males referred for domestic violence. Violence
& Victims. Vol 16(5), 491-506.
Investigated whether childhood
disruptive behavior (hyperactivity, oppositional-defiance, conduct problems)
plus adult psychopathic adjustment are associated with domestic violence.
Ss were 66 adult males in diversion programs. Ss completed the Wender Utah
Rating Scale (WURS), MMPI Psychopathic Deviate scale (PD), Conflict Tactics
Scales representing themselves and their parents, and substance use measures.
Substance use and lifespan antisocial personality (measured by high WURS
and PD scores) were robust predictors of verbal and moderate physical domestic
abuse. Violence in the family of origin was associated with abuse when
tested alone, but failed to exhibit unique association with abuse when
other predictors were taken into account. The possibility that antisocial
batterers respond to contingencies by moderating physical harm, while persisting
at psychological harm, is discussed.
Olson, David E; Stalans,
Loretta J. (2001). Violent offenders on probation: Profile, sentence, and
outcome differences among domestic violence and other violent probationers. Violence
Against Women. 7(10) Oct 2001, 1164-1185.
Compared personal characteristics,
sentencing conditions, and recidivism rates of probationary domestic violence
offenders with those of probationers convicted of other violent offenses.
Probation officers completed data forms for 124 probationers (aged <21-41+
yrs) convicted specifically of domestic violence and 287 probationers convicted
of other violent offenses. Collected data included age, race, gender, education,
prior adult convictions, substance abuse, length of sentence, conditions
of probation, revocation of probation, and technical violations while on
parole. Results show that Ss convicted of domestic violence were more likely
to have a substance abuse history, to be older, White males, to have completed
high school, and to have a prior adult conviction. Sentences for domestic
violence Ss were shorter; however, there were more conditions placed on
the probation period. Recidivism rates for domestic violence Ss were similar
to those convicted of other violent offenses.
Hudak, Koreen Victoria
Bailey. (2001). An investigation of variables related to attrition of Hispanic
men from a domestic violence treatment program.
Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering.
Vol 61(11-B), 6137.
This study examines personality,
demographic, and psychosocial variables of Hispanic batterers involved
in a court-mandated domestic violence treatment program. The objective
of the study was to explore selected MMPI-2 scale differences between batterers
who completed and those who dropped out of treatment. Data were analyzed
on a total of 91 subjects, all of whom were Hispanic males. Variables were
examined to determine if there were identifiable differences between English-speaking
completers (n = 31) and dropouts (n = 21) and Spanish-speaking completers
(n = 25) and dropouts (n = 14). English-speaking dropouts scored significantly
higher on MMPI-2 Scale 4 than did the English-speaking completers. The
MMPI-2 data suggested that the English-speaking dropouts were more immature,
angry, rebellious, impulsive, and at risk for substance abuse than the
English-speaking completers. English-speaking dropouts were also more likely
to be unemployed, to earn less than $12,000 per year, and were slightly
more likely to be single than the English-speaking completers. No significant
differences were found to differentiate the Spanish-speaking dropouts from
completers across personality or demographic variables. However, a trend
was noted that Spanish-speaking dropouts were slightly more likely to have
experienced physical abuse as a child than completers. Recommendations
for future research are presented and implications for program policy are
discussed.
Holtzworth-Munroe, Amy;
Meehan, Jeffrey C; Herron, Katherine; Rehman, Uzma; Stuart, Gregory L.
(2000). Testing the Holtzworth-Munroe and Stuart (1994) batterer typology. Journal
of Consulting & Clinical Psychology. Vol 68(6), 1000-1019.
A. Holtzworth-Munroe and
G. L. Stuart (1994) proposed that 3 subtypes (family only [FO], borderline-dysphoric
[BD], and generally violent-antisocial [GVAI) would be identified using
3 descriptive dimensions (i.e., severity of marital violence, generality
of violence, psychopathology) and would differ on distal and proximal correlates
of violence. Maritally violent men (n = 102) and their wives were recruited
from the community, as were 2 comparison groups of nonviolent couples (i.e.,
maritally distressed and nondistressed). Four clusters of violent men were
identified. Three resembled the predicted subtypes and generally differed
in the manner predicted (e.g., FO men resembled nonviolent groups; BD men
scored highest on measures of dependency and jealousy; GVA men had the
most involvement with delinquent peers, substance abuse, and criminal behavior;
and both BID and GVA men were impulsive, accepted violence, were hostile
toward women, and lacked social skills). The 4th cluster (i.e., low-level
antisocial) fell between the FO and GVA clusters on many measures.
Baugh, Stacey-Ann Robotham.
(2001). An examination of the relationship between male-to-female physical
aggression and psychoactive substance use severity in men entering treatment
for domestic violence. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
61(9-B), 4971.
Domestic violence is a significant
problem in the United States. One out of every six U.S. couples experiences
an incident involving a physical assault each year. Excessive alcohol use
is associated with greater risk for domestic violence. There also appears
to be an increased risk for domestic violence associated with drug use.
Despite the evidence linking substance abuse problems with domestic violence,
surprisingly little research has been conducted examining the relationship
between addiction severity and spousal violence frequency among individuals
entering treatment for domestic violence. The current study examined a
sample of cohabiting couples in which the male partner was entering treatment
for domestic violence. Data was collected one time from both partners within
the couple. Results of the study indicate that greater drug and alcohol
use is significantly related to higher frequency of domestic violence.
However, the interaction of drug and alcohol use did not significantly
predict the frequency of domestic violence. Results of the study also indicated
that perpetrators who met diagnostic criteria for substance abuse diagnoses
had higher frequency of domestic violence incidents than perpetrators who
did not meet these criteria.
Meehan, Jeffrey C; Holtzworth-Munroe,
Amy; Herron, Katherine. (2001). Maritally violent men's heart rate reactivity
to marital interactions: A failure to replicate the Gottman et al. (1995)
typology. Journal of Family
Psychology. Vol 15(3), 394-408.
In an attempt to replicate
the J. A Gottman et al. (1995) batterer typology, 58 men who had engaged
in moderate-to-severe marital violence in the past year were studied. The
sample was split into Gottman et al.'s Type 1 men (i.e., whose heart rates
decreased, from baseline, during a marital conflict task) and Type 2 men
(i.e., whose heart rates increased). The groups did not differ in the manner
predicted on measures of marital violence, antisocial or aggressive-sadistic
personality, drug dependence, criminality, general violence, childhood
exposure to interparental violence, behavior during marital interactions,
or relationship stability. Contrary to expectations, wives of Type 1 men
rated their husband as more jealous and angry and reported more marital
distress. In the only finding consistent with Gottman et al., Type 2 men
scored higher on a measure of dependent personality. Implications for future
research are discussed.
Murphy, Christopher M;
O'Farrell, Timothy J; Fals-Stewart, William; Feehan, Michael. (2001). Correlates
of intimate partner violence among male alcoholic patients. Journal
of Consulting & Clinical Psychology. Vol 69(3) Jun 2001, 528-540.
Male-to-female partner violence
was investigated in heterosexual couples with an alcoholic male partner.
Partner violent (PV) alcoholic patients (n = 183), when compared with nonviolent
(NV) alcoholic patients (n = 120), had more antisocial personality characteristics,
greater alcohol problem severity, greater use of other drugs, higher relationship
distress, and stronger beliefs in the link between alcohol consumption
and relationship problems. Demographic factors did not account for these
PV-NV differences. Relationship distress and alcohol problem severity had
independent associations with partner violence. Relationship adjustment
and drug use remained significantly associated with partner violence, whereas
alcohol problem severity did not, after controlling for patient antisocial
traits. Beliefs in the link between drinking and relationship problems
were associated with partner violence independent of other clinical factors.
Daly, Jennifer Ella. (1998).
Predicting compliance among men who batter: The contribution of demographics,
violence-related factors and psychopathology. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
59(5-B), Nov 1998, 2414
This research examined the
predictors of program attendance and participation among men referred for
batterers' intervention services. Two hundred and twenty men seeking services
at PIVOT of Aid to Victims of Domestic Violence (AVDA), a community-based
batterers' program, completed measures of past battering (Conflict Tactics
Scale, CTS, Straus, 1979), antisocial behavior, and current psychological
functioning (Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test; MAST, Selzer, 1971; Millon
Clinical Multiaxial Inventory, MCMI-III; Millon, 1993). One hundred and
fifty-three women also completed telephone interviews regarding their partners'
past violence and their beliefs about men's compliance. It was predicted
that variables from demographic, violence-related (i.e., battering and
criminal history) and interpersonal (i.e., psychopathology) domains would
predict the number of sessions attended and staff ratings of group participation.
Results indicate that attendance was higher for men who were court-ordered
to attend, men in white collar occupations, men who were employed at intake
and those who scored low on the MAST. Multiple regressions revealed that
only referral source (i.e., court vs. noncourt-ordered), employment status
and presence of alcohol-related problems predicted sessions after equating
men on the other correlates. Staff ratings were higher for men with higher
education and those who reported witnessing battering as children, and
lower for Latino men and men who were unemployed at intake. Only race (i.e.,
Latino) significantly predicted staff ratings of group participation after
controlling for the other variables. Few significant differences were found
in the predictors of attendance or participation for court and noncourt-ordered
men. Exploration of women's predictions of attendance revealed that 96%
(n = 101) believed that their partners' would complete the program. Results
provide valuable information about batterers' attendance and group participation
that can aid victims' decision making and batterer program implementation.
Bennett, Larry W; Tolman,
Richard M; Rogalski, Carol J; Srinivasaraghavan, Jagannathan.
(1994). Domestic abuse
by male alcohol and drug addicts. Violence
& Victims. Vol 9(4) Win 1994, 59-368. Investigated
domestic abuse by male alcoholics and drug addicts. 63 male inpatient alcohol
and drug addicts were interviewed, followed by an interview of 34 of their
female partners to assess the reliability of the men's reports of domestic
abuse. The frequency of both physical and nonphysical abuse were measured.
Results indicate that neither quantity nor frequency of alcohol use nor
the severity of alcohol dependence was associated with an increase in abuse.
Further, domestic abuse by male addicts was not directly related to experience
of violence or addiction in the family of origin, external locus of control
or severity of alcohol abuse. Correlates of domestic abuse were: early
onset of drug/alcohol-related problems; low income; a history of nonalcohol
drug use, particularly cocaine; and a history of arrest and outpatient
counseling.
Murphy, Christopher M;
O'Farrell, Timothy J. (1994). Factors associated with marital aggression
in male alcoholics. Journal of
Family Psychology. Vol 8(3) Sep 1994, 321-335.
Male alcoholics who were
physically aggressive toward their wives in the year before alcoholism
treatment (n = 71) were compared with nonaggressive counterparts (n = 36).
Two key patterns were associated with marital aggression: (a) binge drinking
linked with coercive marital conflicts and (b) markers of a severe early
onset alcoholism syndrome. Maritally aggressive men were younger and exhibited
more binge drinking, higher prevalence of arrest, more verbal aggression,
greater alcohol problem severity, earlier alcohol problem onset, more alcoholism
among male biological relatives, less maternal alcohol use, less confidence
in their ability to manage interpersonal conflict without drinking, and
stronger beliefs that alcohol causes marital problems. Marital adjustment
levels were not associated with marital aggression, and very few differences
were found between moderate and severe violence groups.
Downs, William R; Miller,
Brenda A; Panek, Denise D. (1993). Differential patterns of partner-to-woman
violence: A comparison of samples of community, alcohol-abusing, and battered
women. Journal of Family
Violence. Vol 8(2) Jun 1993, 113-135.
Compared patterns of partner-to-woman
verbal abuse and physical violence among 45 alcoholic women, 38 battered
women, and 40 women randomly selected from the community. Range of violence
and high vs low frequency of violence were measured by Conflict Tactics
Scales (CTS). Results show that at the highest frequency of violence, battered
women reported the highest scores on each CTS subscale. CTS scores of alcoholic
women were higher than those of community women. Membership in the alcoholic
sample significantly predicted a high frequency of negative verbal interaction
and moderate violence, controlling for presence of a partner with alcohol-related
problems and demographic differences among the samples.
Stith, Sandra M; Farley,
Sarah C. A predictive model of male spousal violence. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 8(2) Jun 1993, 183-201.
Developed and tested a multivariate
causal model of predictors of marital violence (MV) by men. Variables examined
were observation of MV during childhood, marital stress, attitude toward
acceptability of MV, sex-role egalitarianism, alcoholism, and self-esteem.
Hypotheses regarding relationships among variables were based on social
learning theory. Path analysis regression was computed based on questionnaire
responses of 91 men in violence or alcoholism treatment programs. Results
suggest that sex-role egalitarianism and approval of MV both have direct
effects on the use of severe MV. Observation of MV had a negative effect
on self-esteem, which influenced marital stress and level of alcoholism
and subsequently influenced approval of MV. Observation of MV as a child
also had a direct effect on approval of MV and a negative effect on sex-role
egalitarianism.
Julian, Teresa W; McKenry,
Patrick C. (1993). Mediators of male violence toward female intimates. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 8(1) Mar 1993, 39-56.
Compared perceived life
stressors, alcohol usage, and perceived quality of the intimate relationship
among 42 men who had abused their female intimate with 50 men with no history
of partner abuse. Ss completed various demographic and health questions
as well as the Michigan Alcoholism Screen Test, E. S. Schaefer and M. Edgerton's
(1982) Autonomy/Relatedness Scale, the Life Experiences Survey, and the
Conflict-Tactics Scale. Stepwise logistic regression indicated that higher
perceived quality of the intimate relationship, race, and greater depression
were significant predictors of male violence toward female intimates. (PsycINFO
Database Record (c) 2000 APA, all rights reserved) (unassigned)
Dinwiddie, Stephen H.
(1992). Psychiatric disorders among wife batterers. Comprehensive
Psychiatry. Vol 33(6) Nov-Dec 1992, 411-416.
61 male spouse batterers
were identified from a population of relatives of treated alcoholics and
compared with 319 married or formerly married men without a reported history
of battering on lifetime psychiatric diagnoses and antecedent behaviors.
Batterers had higher lifetime rates of alcoholism, antisocial personality
disorder, and depression than nonbatterers, but not other psychiatric disorders.
While batterers and nonbatterers could not be differentiated based on violent
behaviors occurring before the age of 15 yrs, 95% of batterers reported
other fighting as an adult. Batterers were more likely to have been divorced
2 or more times and to report repeated infidelity.
Stith, Sandra M; Crossman,
Rita K; Bischof, Gary P. (1991). Alcoholism and marital violence: A comparative
study of men in alcohol treatment programs and batterer treatment programs. Alcoholism
Treatment Quarterly. Vol 8(2) 1991, 3-20.
Compared 39 men enrolled
in batterer programs and 52 men enrolled in alcohol treatment programs
on factors related to marital violence. All Ss were currently in a relationship.
Factors that were compared included age, education, income, race, marital
status, current level of marital stress, level of self-esteem, socially
desirable response bias, attitude toward marital violence, level of sex-role
egalitarianism, history of childhood violence, level of violence in current
relationship, and level of alcohol abuse. Very few differences between
the men were found on any of the variables. The majority of men in both
groups were alcoholics (64% of the men in the batterer programs and 96%
of the men in alcohol programs) and used violent conflict tactics in their
relationships (82% of the men in batterer programs and 59% of those in
alcohol programs). Implications for treatment of dually affected men are
presented.
Gondolf, Edward W; Foster,
Robert A. (1991). Wife assault among VA alcohol rehabilitation patients. Hospital
& Community Psychiatry. Vol 42(1) Jan 1991, 74-79.
Administered the short Michigan
Alcoholism Screening Test and the Conflict Tactics Scales to 218 patients
in a Veterans Affairs (VA) alcohol rehabilitation program for military
veterans. More than 33% of the Ss reported assaulting their wives or partners
at least once in the previous year, and 20% reported committing severe
assaults. A subsample of 33 wives or partners of the Ss reported higher
rates of assault than did their male partners. An examination of clinical
records of 25 Ss indicated that clinicians had identified some sort of
"domestic violence" for only 20% of this subsample. A dysfunctional family
of origin and previous arrest were associated with higher rates of wife
assault.
Rooney, Jennifer; Hanson,
R. Karl. (2001). Predicting attrition from treatment programs for abusive
men. Journal of Family Violence.
Vol 16(2), 131-149.
Attrition in male battering
treatment programs is a serious problem. To keep clients in treatment,
it is crucial to understand why they drop out. The current study examined
the contribution of both client and program characteristics in predicting
dropout from treatment programs for abusive men. Data were collected at
intake from 306 abusive men (mean age 35.5 yrs) who sought treatment at
4 different sites. The rate of preprogram attrition (from intake to the
first treatment session) was higher in the program that had a lengthy waiting
list than in the other programs. In-program attrition was more highly related
to client characteristics than program characteristics. Those men who dropped
out after starting treatment tended to have unstable lifestyles (e.g.,
substance abuse problems, criminal history, unemployment) and to have inflicted
more severe abuse than those who completed treatment. Results also supported
a significant interaction between verbal aptitude and structure of program;
men with low verbal aptitude were the most likely to drop out of an unstructured
program. Possible strategies for preventing attrition are discussed.
White, Robert Jeffrey.
(2000). Self-reported woman battering, personality characteristics and
substance abuse of low security federal prison inmates. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
61(4-B), 2230.
This study describes woman
battering, personality characteristics and substance abuse reported by
115 inmates entering a low security federal prison. The objective is to
describe the extent and characteristics of woman batterers in a large,
understudied male population. The research questions are; (1) To what extent
do inmates acknowledge battering and present characteristics associated
with battering? (2) How can self-identified inmate batterers be characterized
in terms of personality functioning and substance abuse? and (3) How do
these characteristics inform batterers interventions in low security federal
prisons? Archival data from Psychology Services files was examined for
115 inmates who completed consecutive, mandatory intake assessments between
February and July 1998. Assessments occurred within 30 days of inmates'
arrival to the prison and consisted of the Conflict Tactics Scale, Michigan
Alcohol Screening Test, Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory, Version Three,
and the standard Psychology Services intake questionnaire. Characteristics
of the full inmate sample and the subsarnple of inmates who admitted battering
on the Conflict Tactics Scale are described and treatment implications
are discussed. The full sample approximates the composition of the prison
and of low security Federal prisons. The inmates report high levels of
identified risk factors for woman battering, in particular substance abuse,
and 1 in 3 acknowledge recent physical violence against women partners.
The 38 self-identified batterers exhibit high rates of antisocial personality
tendencies and substance use problems. Systematic groupings of their personality
profiles suggest, nonetheless, that the prevailing trimodal batterer typology
is represented. The findings suggest that screening for domestic violence
may be needed in low security federal prisons for a large, rapidly growing
male population that ultimately returns to society and that the established,
gender-based, cognitive-behavioral batterers intervention model may be
appropriate with important modifications. Batterers programs in these facilities
may need to accommodate borderline/dysphoric and psychopathic tendencies
that characterize inmate batterers, address substance abuse problems, and
adopt programs to institutional realities. The findings and implications
are considered tentative and suggest future research directions.
Conner, Kenneth R; Duberstein,
Paul R; Conwell, Yeates. (2000). Domestic violence, separation and suicide
in young men with early onset alcoholism: Reanalyses of Murphy's data.
. Suicide
& Life-Threatening Behavior. Vol 30(4) Win 2000, 354-359.
Investigated partner violence
and partner separation at the time of completed suicide in 42 male alcoholics
originally described by G. E. Murphy (1992). Data was based on psychological
autopsies. Results show that half of the men had domestic violence histories.
Partner-violent men were younger, had an earlier age of onset of alcoholism,
and were more likely to be separated from their partner at the time of
death than partner-nonviolent men. Loss of a close personal relationship,
often a domestic partner, was common during the last year of life among
alcoholic men completing suicide. Domestic violence appears to typify many
of their domestic relationships, particularly among younger men and men
with early onset alcoholism.
Soler, Hosanna; Vinayak,
Preeti; Quadagno, David. (2000). Biosocial aspects of domestic violence. Psychoneuroendocrinology.
Vol 25(7), 721-739.
Examined the relationships
between a biological variable (testosterone level), social variables (demographics,
social integration), and behavior (substance use) and self-reported domestic
violence. The sample consisted of 54 men (aged 18-45 yrs) who had a main
sexual partner and who identified themselves as Black, White, or Hispanic.
The men were recruited from various social-service agency sites in the
area of Miami, Florida, on the basis of their risk factors for HIV/AIDS.
Ss completed the Conflict Tactics Scale. A high percentage of Ss reported
some level of both verbal and physical aggression towards their partners.
Testosterone levels were significantly associated with levels of both verbal
aggression and physical violence self-reported by the men. Testosterone
level, demographic characteristics, and alcohol consumption contributed
to explaining the variance in self-reported verbal and physical abuse.
Easton, Caroline; Swan,
Suzanne; Sinha, Rajita. (2000). Motivation to change substance use among
offenders of domestic violence. Journal
of Substance Abuse Treatment. Vol 19(1), 1-5.
Given the high rates of
co-occurring substance use (SU) and family violence-related problems, SU
was assessed in 41 male offenders of domestic violence (aged 18-64 yrs)
who were mandated by court to attend anger management classes. Rates of
substance dependence diagnoses ranged from 33% to 50%, while rates of substance
abuse diagnoses ranged from 60% to 75%. This study evaluated the effectiveness
of a motivational enhancement intervention on readiness to change SU in
these 41 Ss. Two anger management groups were targeted to assess SU, violence,
and motivation to change SU behaviors. One group was randomly chosen to
partake in a motivational enhancement intervention session. The comparison
group was offered standard anger management classes. A brief motivation
to change survey, adapted from the Readiness to Change subscale of the
Stages of Change Readiness and Treatment Eagerness Scale, was administered
pre- and postsession. Results indicate that a motivational enhancement
intervention is feasible and effective in increasing readiness to change
SU among domestic violence offenders. The results illustrate the importance
of assessing and treating substance use among offenders of domestic violence
as this may be an important indicator for higher dropout rates and reoffending.
Bresnahan, Sean Patrick.
(1999). Men who are violent against their partners: A study evaluating
the effectiveness of a domestic violence treatment program in a correctional
setting. Dissertation Abstracts
International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol 60(3-B),
1289
Over the past 15 years,
much research has been conducted regarding the effectiveness of programs
developed to treat men specifically for abusing their partners. The research
tends to show mixed results (Eckhardt, Barbour, & Stuart, 1997; Barbour,
Eckhardt, Davison, & Kassinove, 1998) for two reasons. The first is
methodological research designs which are faulty due to such problem as
lack of control groups and high drop-out rates. The second reason is treatment
programs have primarily focused on nonpersonality factors such as substance
abuse and the stress of daily living. The purpose of this present study
was to evaluate the efficacy of a violence-reduction program on behavior
and psychological characteristics of intimate abusers, while making an
effort to avoid the methodological flaws related to recent studies. This
was done by comparing a group of intimately abusive offenders (N = 12)
who completed an eight week, cognitive-behavioral treatment program with
a group of offenders (N =1 2) who were comparable to the treated offenders
but were not yet in treatment for administrative reasons. The entire sample
was administered a battery of measures prior to the treatment program in
order to identify core psychological variables. They were then measured
at the conclusion of the treatment program on those same variables. The
results were then compared to the pretest measures' and to the separate
samples. In this study, the results indicated that there were few significant
changes between pre-treatment and post-treatment measures for the treatment
group, as compared to the control group. It was found that the treatment
program may have significantly reduced total hostility as measured by the
Buss-Durkee Hostility Inventory (Buss, & Durkee, 1957). This suggests
that these men who participated in the treatment program significantly
reduced their levels of verbal hostility, indirect hostility, suspicion,
negativism, irritability, resentment, and assault, as compared to the control
group. Additionally, the subscale verbal hostility on the Buss-Durkee Hostility
Inventory (Buss et al., 1957) was significantly reduced while the subscale
attitude toward the law, as measured by the Criminal Sentiment Scale (Gendreau,
Grant, Leipciger, & Collins, 1979, Andrews, & Wormith, 1984; Sheilds,
& Simourd, 1991) significantly increased. However, the remaining results
indicated that the treatment program did not have an affect on criminal
sentiment, or locus of control. On the other hand, as was expected, most
of the identified psychological characteristics fell within the normative
ranges found from previous research, which supports the prevalence of these
features in intimate abusers. Even though the results were not able to
significantly predict placement in the treatment group as opposed to the
control group on any of the factors measured, the best predictor turned
out to be total hostility on the Buss-Durkee measure (Buss et al., 1957).
In the future, longitudinal studies should be conducted in order to evaluate
the stability of changes achieved by the Domestic Violence Reduction Group
or the relationship between the changes that were experienced and subsequent
behavior within their relationships and the community longitudinally. In
addition, the research should focus on recidivism rates and offense.
Francis, Elie; Hughes,
Patrick; Schinka, John. (1999). Improving cost-effectiveness in a substance
abuse treatment program. Psychiatric
Services. Vol 50(5) May 1999, 633-635.
Describes the reorganization
process of a Veterans Affairs substance abuse program in response to needs
for more cost-efficiency. The challenge was to transform the inpatient-focused
program into a comprehensive ambulatory care service for patients who are
largely homeless and unemployed and who have very limited family support
or transportation capabilities. Needs of patients and referring services
were assessed through the use of task forces, and decisions were made on
which services would be most effective and would best meet the needs of
clients. Program building blocks included the elimination of consultation
waiting lists and the addition of an intensive outpatient day program,
an intensive evening rehabilitation program, a relapse prevention program,
an outpatient detoxification clinic, and a domestic violence intervention
program. This substance abuse program was successfully restructured in
a way that encourages cost-effectiveness while maintaining accountability
and quality of care.
O'Farrell, Timothy J;
Van Hutton, Valerie; Murphy, Christopher M. (1999). Domestic violence before
and after alcoholism treatment: A two-year longitudinal study. Journal
of Studies on Alcohol. Vol 60(3), 317-321.
An initial study of 88 male
alcoholics and their wives had shown that domestic violence decreased significantly
in the year following a behavioral marital therapy (BMT) alcoholism treatment
program (see record 1995-25613-001). To determine if violence reductions
were stable, the present study examined the prevalence and frequency of
domestic violence during the 2nd year following BMT for the 75 of the original
couples (mean age 45 yrs) who provided 2-yr follow-up data on violence.
Comparison rates of domestic violence were derived from a nationally representative
survey of violence in American families. For both the 1st and 2nd year
after BMT, violence was significantly reduced and the extent of violence
was associated with the extent of the alcoholics' drinking. Frequency of
posttreatment drinking was positively correlated with violence, and remitted
alcoholics no longer had elevated domestic violence levels when compared
with controls whereas relapsed alcoholics did. Results indicate that domestic
violence decreased after BMT alcoholism treatment. Further, among remitted
alcoholics, violence returned to the level experienced by other families,
in the same way that other aspects of marital, family and psychosocial
functioning improve after successful treatment of alcoholism.
Brown, Thomas G; Werk,
Annette; Caplan, Tom; Seraganian, Peter. (1999). Violent substance abusers
in domestic violence treatment. Violence
& Victims. Vol 14(2), 179-190.
This study had 2 main objectives:
(1) the characterization of psychoactive substance abuse disorders; and
(2) clarification of the role of substance abuse on the sociodemographic,
personality, psychosocial, and abuse characteristics of dual-problem men.
53 adult men who were attending domestic violence treatment were recruited.
They were administered the Addiction Severity Index, the Conflicts Tactics
Scale, Structured Clinical Diagnostic, the Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire,
and the Symptoms Checklist-90. 63% of the men had a current diagnosis of
psychoactive substance abuse or dependence, while 92% had a lifetime diagnosis.
Of the former, the majority was diagnosed as multiply dependent on alcohol
and other drugs. Dual-problem men reported more hostility, apprehension,
frustration and suspiciousness and past arrests than did their violence-only
cohorts as well as a history of multiple (unsuccessful) treatment for substance
abuse. These findings suggest that the trend toward multiple drug complaints
seen in other clinical milieus is also being confronted in conjugal violence
settings.
Gondolf, Edward W. (1999).
Characteristics of court-mandated batterers in four cities: Diversity and
dichotomies. Violence Against
Women. Vol 5(11), 1277-1293.
Background and test data,
including information from the Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test and the
Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory-III, were systematically collected
from 840 Ss (aged 18-65 yrs) from 4 geographically distributed batterer
programs. Results show that the Ss appeared similar demographically to
those in previous portrayals of court-mandated batterers, except that this
sample had a greater portion of African American and Latino Ss. Several
dichotomies appeared among the Ss that might influence intervention, such
as differences in living arrangements, education, employment, and drinking.
Over half of the Ss had been arrested for offenses other than domestic
violence. Over half of the Ss had alcoholic tendencies, and over one quarter
showed evidence of several mental disorders. The 4 programs reflected regional
differences in demographics but had relatively similar portions of Ss with
previous arrests, mental problems, and alcoholic tendencies.
Koch, Gregory Lee. (1998).
Previous arrests, alcoholism, psychopathology, and performance in court-mandated
treatment for domestic violence. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
59(2-B), 0875
Problem. The purpose of
this study was to investigate the relationship between previous arrests,
alcoholism, psychopathology and treatment attendance for domestic violence
offenders enrolled in court-mandated psychoeducational treatment. The study
also examined the relationship between previous arrests, alcoholism, psychopathology,
and participation in treatment. Method. 62 male Subjects enrolled in a
court-mandated domestic violence psychoeducational treatment program were
administered the Michigan Alcohol Screening Test (MAST) and the Minnesota
Multiphasic Personality Inventory-2 (MMPI-2). Subjects were also interviewed
regarding previous arrests and contacts with the police. Treatment attendance
records were compiled and subjects' participation in treatment was analyzed.
The resulting data were analyzed using correlation techniques and multiple
regression tests in order to explain the relationship between the variables.
Results. The study revealed that domestic violence offenders receiving
court-mandated treatment typically had been arrested or had had contact
with the police before the arrest for which they were being treated. The
mean MAST indicated that the typical subject had a rather severe alcohol
problem. MMPI-2 mean scores indicated that the average subject scored in
the normal range on the F Scale and in the high normal range of the Psychopathic
Deviate Scale. In examining the relationship between the variables, previous
arrests were significantly negatively correlated with both number of treatment
sessions attended and the quality and level of participation in treatment.
The MMPI-2 F Scale was not significantly correlated with number of treatment
sessions attended or with the quality and level of participation in treatment,
although the relationship between the F Scale and the number of treatment
sessions attended approached statistical significant. The relationships
between MAST scores and both number of treatment sessions attended and
the quality and level of participation in treatment were not significant.
When previous arrests, MAST score, F Scale score, and Psychopathic Deviate
Scale score were included in various combinations to analyze their relationship
with number of treatment sessions attended and with quality and level of
participation in treatment, only the combination of previous arrests and
the MMPI-2 F Scale score was significantly correlated with number of treatment
sessions attended. None of the independent variable combinations was significantly
related to quality and level of participation in treatment.
Teoh-Goh, Daphne Phaik-Kin.
(1997). The phenomenon of wife beating among males in treatment for alcoholism
and domestic violence. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
57(10-B), 6597
This study investigated
variables hypothesized to be correlated with wife beating among males in
treatment for alcoholism and domestic violence. Specifically, it was hypothesized
that there would significant positive correlations between stress, alcoholism,
attitude toward women, attitude toward violence against women, being severely
punished as a child and observation of parental spousal violence in the
family of origin, and violent behaviour toward an intimate partner. The
sample consisted of 70 males, recruited from county-approved treatment
programs for alcoholism and domestic violence. Respondents completed a
survey instrument containing a demographic questionnaire, two inventories
specially designed for this study to measure the degree of physical violence
experienced (PE) as a child and degree of violence observed between parents
(VO), and four published instruments to measure stress (Life Experiences
Survey), severity of alcoholism (Short Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test),
attitude toward women (Attitude Toward Women Scale), and beliefs about
wife beating (Inventory of Beliefs about Wife-Beating). The dependent variable
was measured with two instruments: the Conflict Tactics Scale, which measured
violent and nonviolent means of conflict resolutions, and the Abusive Behavior
Inventory, an inventory of physically and psychologically abusive behaviours.
Correlational analyses found significant support for the hypothesized relationship
between observation of violence between parents and respondents' own violent
behaviour and psychological abuse perpetrated against their intimate partners.
Additionally, respondents who believe that wife-beating is justified, and
that wives gain from being physically abused, are also more likely to have
engaged physical violence and psychological abuse against their intimate
partners. Among this sample, stress and alcohol abuse were not found to
be related to wife beating. Stepwise multiple regression analyses found
further support for the results of the correlational analyses. That is,
violence observed between parents accounted for 15% of the variance in
wife beating. Believing that wife-beating is justified accounted for an
additional 5% of the variance. Results of this study were discussed in
relation to findings of previous studies. Clinical implications of the
results were explored. Assumptions and limitations of this study were discussed,
followed by recommendations for future research.
Lee, W. Vernon; Gottheil,
Edward; Sterling, Robert C; Weinstein, Stephen P; Serota, Ronald D. (1997).
Characteristics of cocaine-addicted individuals who abuse their partners. Journal
of Substance Abuse Treatment. Vol 14(4), 367-371.
Attempted to determine what
proportion of individuals entering treatment for cocaine dependence admitted
to battering an intimate partner and compared the characteristics of those
who were not identified as batterers. Of the 77 men in the sample, 29 (38%)
were characterized as cocaine-dependent batterers. The batterers and nonbatterers
were found to differ on a variety of background and assessment variables.
Cocaine-dependent batterers more often reported a history of serious conflict
with their sexual partner, trouble controlling violent behavior, greater
psychiatric disturbance, difficulty relaxing, and being easily annoyed.
Murphy, Christopher M;
O'Farrell, Timothy J. (1997). Couple communication patterns of maritally
aggressive and nonaggressive male alcoholics. Journal
of Studies on Alcohol. Vol 58(1), 83-90.
Studied the links between
communication problems and marital violence in couples with a male alcoholic,
and compared them with those of nonalcoholic community samples. 90 newly-abstinent
male alcoholics and their wives completed a 10-min problem discussion while
both partners were sober. Their communication behaviors were also recorded
and coded. The couples were grouped either into nonaggressive husbands
and their wives (mean ages 48.1 and 45.6 yrs), or physically aggressive
husbands and their wives (mean ages 40.7 and 38.0 yrs). Results showed
that: (1) there were more aversive-defensive communication for couples
with a physically aggressive husband; (2) there were similar levels of
facilitative-enhancing communication in both groups, but generally displayed
less by alcoholic husbands than their wives; (3) the physically aggressive
husbands, but not their wives, showed more negative reciprocity than the
nonaggressive husbands.
Schafer, John; Fals-Stewart,
William. (1997). Spousal violence and cognitive functioning among men recovering
from multiple substance abuse. Addictive
Behaviors. Vol 22(1), 127-130.
Experimental research suggests
that substance use is associated with increased aggression, and other research
suggests that substance use is also a risk factor in spousal violence.
In addition, neuropsychological status is associated with both spousal
violence and substance abuse. This study builds on previous work demonstrating
an association between lower levels of performance on a brief neuropsychological
test battery and higher levels of total couple, husband-to-wife, and severe
husband-to-wife violence for 31 married men recovering from multiple substance
abuse.
Downs, William R; Smyth,
Nancy J; Miller, Brenda A. (1996). The relationship between childhood violence
and alcohol problems among men who batter: An empirical review and synthesis. Aggression
& Violent Behavior. Vol 1(4), 327-344.
The available literature
indicates that: (a) experiences of childhood violence are associated with
mediator variables, including antisocial behaviors and depressive symptomatology;
(b) experiences of childhood violence and observation of interpersonal
violence during childhood predict perpetration of partner violence in adulthood
for men; (c) presence of partner violence is associated with certain types
of alcohol problems for men; (d) both partner violence and alcohol problems
are associated with marital conflict. Based on available research, two
indirect pathways between childhood violence and adulthood problems are
proposed as guides for future research in the areas of family violence
and alcohol problems for men. Bidirectional associations between alcohol
problems and partner violence are proposed. Finally, inclusion of important
moderator and mediator variables in multivariate research designs is suggested.
Murphy, Christopher M;
O'Farrell, Timothy J. (1996). Marital violence among alcoholics.Current
Directions in Psychological Science. Vol 5(6), 183-186.
Discusses initial studies
that have shown that a high proportion of male alcoholics seeking treatment
have been violent toward their wives, and that have identified factors
that may help to explain this association. The authors argue that male
alcoholics who physically abuse their partners differ in important ways
from alcoholics who do not, displaying a cluster of signs associated with
a severe, early onset form of alcoholism, including an inheritance pattern
largely limited to male relatives and previous arrests. The maritally violent
alcoholics are also more likely to binge drink, have more negative styles
of communicating with their spouses, and maintain strong beliefs about
the negative influences of alcohol on marriage. Initial evidence suggests
that cessation of problem drinking after alcoholism treatment involving
the spouse is associated with significant and substantial reductions in
marital violence, whereas relapse to drinking after such treatment is associated
with continued marital violence.
Maiden, R. Paul. (1996).
The incidence of domestic violence among alcoholic EAP clients before and
after treatment. Employee
Assistance Quarterly. Vol 11(3), 21-46.
Examined the effect of an
employee assistance program (EAP) on domestic violence with 80 clients
referred for alcoholism treatment. Ss completed the Conflict Tactics Scale.
94% of Ss had engaged in behavior ranging from verbal intimidation to severe
physical aggression prior to intervention. Moderate physical aggression
and verbal intimidation continued to be reported after intervention. Regular
attendance at AA and frequent sponsor contact were significant in reducing
domestic violence. Post-intervention domestic violence suggests a continued
pattern of violence but with less frequency and severity. Implications
for EAP practitioners are considered.
Jarman, Randall W. (1991).
An investigation of alcohol, personality and violence variables in predicting
treatment attendance for wife battering men. Dissertation
Abstracts International. Vol 52(3-B), 1767
Hamberger, L. Kevin; Hastings,
James E. (1991). Personality correlates of men who batter and nonviolent
men: Some continuities and discontinuities. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 6(2) 131-147.
Investigated personality
and family-of-origin differences among 38 male batterers referred for treatment
who were alcoholic, 61 who were nonalcoholic, 28 community-identified maritally
violent males, and 64 male nonviolent controls. Multivariate analyses of
variance (MANOVAs) of the Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory (MCMI) showed
that alcoholic and nonalcoholic batterers showed higher levels of borderline
characteristics. Alcoholic batterers showed the highest MCMI elevations,
followed by nonalcoholic batterers. Community-identified batterers showed
no predicted significant differences from the nonviolent controls. On measures
of family-of-origin pathology and disruption, only alcoholic batterers
differed significantly from nonbatterers on both experienced and witnessed
abuse victimization.
Zweig, Janine M; Schlichter,
Kathryn A; Burt, Martha R. (2002). Assisting women victims of violence
who experience multiple barriers to services. Violence
Against Women. Vol 8,162-180.
Examined the extent to which
programs for domestic violence and sexual assault gear services toward
women facing multiple barriers (i.e., substance abuse disorders, mental
health problems or learning disabilities, incarceration, and prostitution)
and the unique problems such women encounter when accessing services. As
part of a national evaluation, the authors interviewed staff from 20 programs
focusing their service efforts on multibarriered women. Results show that
problems encountered by such women include lack of services dealing with
multiple barriers, uneducated service providers, and batterers using women's
barriers to further control or victimize them. The strategies programs
use to meet these women's distinct needs are described.
Testa, Maria; Leonard,
Kenneth E. (2001). The impact of marital aggression on women's psychological
and marital functioning in a newlywed sample. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 16(2), 115-130.
The impact of husband-to-wife
physical aggression on changes in wives' personal and marital well-being
was examined in a representative sample of newlywed couples. The sample
consisted of 543 couples who completed baseline and first anniversary assessments.
After controlling for sociodemographic variables, initial relationship
satisfaction, and verbal aggression, wives who experienced physical aggression
from their husbands during the first year of marriage reported increased
stress and lower marital satisfaction at the first anniversary. Further,
they were more likely to report separation from husbands due to marital
problems during the first year of marriage. Experiences of partner physical
aggression during the premarital period were associated with greater frequency
of heavy drinking episodes among wives, although they were not associated
with changes in average daily volume of ethanol consumed. Results suggest
that among a community sample, experiences of husband-to-wif e physical
aggression have negative consequences for both women's psychological well-being
and marital functioning.
Kelly, Patricia J; Blacksin,
Beth; Mason, Ellen. (2001). Factors affecting substance abuse treatment
completion for women. Issues in Mental Health Nursing. Vol 22(3),287-304.
Substance abuse by women
is considered an individual pathology, and the larger social processes
of recovery are seldom explored. This research study examined social factors
that influenced completion of an outpatient women-centered substance abuse
treatment program. The treatment records of a group of 15 pregnant women
who completed the program were compared with a group who did not complete
the program. More completers had previous life successes in the areas of
education, job skills, and employment history. Completers also had fewer
children, less involvement with child protective services, and lower levels
of chaos, a construct that included the presence of two of any of the following
in women's lives: child protective services, homelessness, psychiatric
diagnosis, or domestic violence. Completion of substance abuse treatment
seems more likely for women with personal and social resources. If programs
are to be successful, adequate funding must be provided for both assessment
and support of the social problems encountered by the most vulnerable women.
Hirsch, Amy E. (2001).
"The world was never a safe place for them": Abuse, welfare reform and
women with drug convictions. Violence
Against Women. Vol 7(2), 159-175.
Tolman, Richard M; Rosen,
Daniel. (2001). Domestic violence in the lives of women receiving welfare. Violence
Against Women. Vol 7(2), 141-158.
Using data from 753 women
(aged 18-54 yrs) from the welfare caseload in an urban Michigan county,
the authors investigate the prevalence of domestic violence and its association
with mental health, health, and economic well-being. Data was collected
in the areas of domestic violence, health, mental health, maternal deprivation,
and employment and welfare status. Nearly a quarter of the women experienced
physical partner violence in the past 12 mo, and almost two thirds in their
lifetimes. Recent victims had significantly higher rates of 5 psychiatric
disorders (depression, generalized anxiety disorder, post-traumatic stress
disorder, drug dependence, and alcohol dependence) and health problems
than women who never experienced domestic violence. Recent partner violence
was also associated with greater material hardship.
Freeman Gustafson, Carl
Scott. (2001). Re-viewing treatment for female addicted victims of domestic
violence. Dissertation Abstracts
International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol 60(12-B),
2000, 6361.
This study explores the
intervention strategies used by providers while working with women who
are addicted victims of domestic violence ('AVDV'). The central hypothesis
of this study is that the current treatment system traditionally views
substance abuse and domestic violence as two distinct problems with two
separate sets of interventions being provided by separate service providers.
The intent is to facilitate a discussion that may lead to a re-viewing
of intervention strategies, with the hypothesis that more integrated treatment
or increased cooperation between providers will lead to reduced recidivism,
decreases in the gaps in service delivery and may save women's lives. The
object of this inquiry is to obtain data from service providers in three
states: Alabama, California and Massachusetts. The goal is to asses what
services are offered, how the services are being provided, and the extent
and nature of any cooperative treatment with other providers. Descriptive
analysis of programmatic practices, client and provider demographic features
is utilized to assess and characterize the data.
Steele, Caryl Trotter.
(2000). Providing clinical treatment to substance abusing trauma survivors. Alcoholism
Treatment Quarterly. Vol 18(3), 71-81.
Research and clinical observation
have shown that women seeking substance abuse treatment are more likely
to he victims of interpersonal violence than those in the general population.
Such research clearly marks a close association between early interpersonal
violence and subsequent development of substance abuse and dependency.
Survivors of violence are likely to become dependent upon chemicals as
a way to reduce tension rather than learn other ways of managing stress.
To produce successful treatment outcomes, both disorders must be treated
together. Some of the theoretical models that help to explain the causes,
consequences, and clinical implications of interpersonal abuse are described.
A classification system is described to understand the timing issues involved
for treatment planning. Descriptions of a developmental model of treatment
for unresolved posttraumatic stress disorder and addictions is offered.
Concluding remarks include notations from the author's experience in working
with this dual model and diagnosis.
Kimerling, Rachel; Goldsmith, Rachel. (2000). Links between exposure to violence and HIV-infection: Implications for substance abuse treatment with women. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly. Vol 18(3), 61-69. Among women, a history of exposure to violence is associated with both an increased likelihood of substance use and an increased risk of HIV-infection. Thus substance use and other behaviors which can affect the risk of HIV exposure are often influenced by the psychosocial sequelae of violent victimization. Because these issues are interrelated, mental health interventions focused on any one of these issues in isolation may be less effective than in integrated approach. The current paper reviews the extant literature on these topics and proposes that treatment of women substance users must address the relationships between psychological trauma and increased HIV-risk behaviors and that attention to substance abuse and psychological trauma are necessary foci of services to HIV-infected women.
Miller, Brenda A; Wilsnack,
Sharon C; Cunradi, Carol B. (2000). Family violence and victimization:
Treatment issues for women with alcohol problems. Alcoholism:
Clinical & Experimental Research. Vol 24(8), 1287-1297.
Presents a brief overview
of the prevalence of violence in women's lives and psychological and physical
consequences of these experiences, with special attention to populations
of women with alcohol and other drug problems. The authors discuss barriers
to identification of violent victimization within health care settings
and identify potential areas for future consideration regarding policy,
practice, and research. Also, the authors document the relationships between
women's experiences of violent victimization and their use of alcohol and
drugs, although prior research has not fully explained or explored the
etiological nature of these relationships. Of additional importance is
the recognition that various forms of violence occur throughout a single
life span. Women's histories of violent victimization negatively affect
their children, and thus, intergenerational issues are of concern. The
authors believe that understanding how the combined problems of alcohol
and drugs interconnect with violence is relevant to the delivery of health
services for women.
Brown, Vivian B; Melchior,
Lisa A; Panter, A. T; Slaughter, Ruth; Huba, G. J. (2000). Women's steps
of change and entry into drug abuse treatment: A multidimensional stages
of change model. Journal of Substance
Abuse Treatment. Vol 18(3), 231-240.
The Transtheoretical, or
Stages of Change Model, has been applied to the investigation of help-seeking
related to a number of addictive behaviors. Overall, the model has shown
to be very important in understanding the process of help-seeking. However,
substance abuse rarely exists in isolation from other health, mental health,
and social problems. The present work extends the original Stages of Change
Model by proposing "Steps of Change" as they relate to entry into substance
abuse treatment programs for women. The Steps of Change Model hypothesizes
that help-seeking behavior of substance-abusing women may reflect a hierarchy
of readiness based on the immediacy, or time urgency, of their treatment
issues. Readiness to make life changes in 4 domains--domestic violence,
HIV sexual risk behavior, substance abuse, and mental health--was examined
among 451 women (aged 15-69 yrs) in relation to entry into 4 substance
abuse treatment modalities (12-step, detoxification, outpatient, and residential).
A series of logistic regression analyses predicted entry into 4 separate
treatment modalities. In general, Ss in the preparation and action stages
were more likely to enter drug treatment, whereas clients in the precontemplation
and contemplation stages were less likely to enter treatment. Results suggest
a multidimensional Stages of Change Model that may extend to other populations
and to other types of help-seeking behaviors.
El-Bassel, Nabila; Gilbert,
Louisa; Schilling, Robert; Wada, Takeshi. (2000). Drug abuse and partner
violence among women in methadone treatment. Journal
of Family Violence. Vol 15(3), 209-228.
Aimed to (1) describe rates
of lifetime and current partner abuse among women on methadone; (2) examine
the relationship between partner violence and demographics, substance abuse,
and drug risk behaviors; and (3) explore the association between a victim's
current use of crack/cocaine, heroin, marijuana, and drug risk behavior
after controlling for demographics, household composition, history of victimization
and sex trading. 145 women participated in this study (mean age 38.5 yrs).
Approximately three-fourths of the women ever experienced physical, sexual,
or life-threatening abuse and slightly less than one-third experienced
at least one type of abuse during the previous year. A history of childhood
victimization was reported by more than half of the women and one-third
witnessed her mother being abused. Risk of partner violence was associated
with victim's current drug and alcohol use, visiting shooting galleries,
and living with someone with drug or alcohol problems. The study discusses
the implications of the findings for research and intervention.
Simpson, Tracy Lynn. (1999).
An exploration of the functional roles of alcohol use among women drinkers.
(childhood sexual abuse, sexual abuse).
Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering.
Vol 60(4-B), 1873
Substantial evidence indicates
that women with substance abuse problems report markedly higher rates of
childhood sexual abuse (CSA) than do women in the general population. It
has been frequently postulated that a history of CSA is a critical mediator
of both the development of substance abuse, and of relapse among many women
with alcohol and drug problems. Four groups of women (N = 141) were assessed
regarding the functional roles of their alcohol consumption and their treatment
histories: women with and without histories of CSA seeking treatment for
alcohol-related problems and non-problem drinking women with and without
histories of CSA. Three aspects of the functional role of alcohol were
assessed: alcohol expectancies, reasons for drinking, and the reported
actual effects obtained from drinking. The results indicate that a history
of CSA is associated with increased risk of meeting diagnostic criteria
for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among both problem and non-problem
drinking women, and that CSA status is not a marker of other current distress.
The anticipated differences in functions of drinking across CSA groups
were not found. Analyses involving the women in treatment found that current
PTSD status was associated with drinking to facilitate social interactions,
positive experiences, and verbal expression of feelings, and to punish
oneself. They also reported more often obtaining the following effects
from drinking: increased feelings of power, enhanced social interactions
and positive experiences, and reduced problems with negative affect and
PTSD-like symptoms. These results indicate that PTSD status is more clearly
associated with drinking to cope than is CSA status. Other results from
the present study revealed that women in treatment with CSA histories have
received slightly less treatment for substance abuse problems and slightly
more psychological services than did their nonabused peers. However, women
with lifetime histories of PTSD, whether they were also sexually abused
as children, report more overall treatment than did those without PTSD.
The specific patterns of treatment utilization (substance abuse treatment
versus psychological treatment) were found to vary as a function of both
PTSD status and CSA status. The theoretical and clinical implications of
these findings are discussed.
Melchior, Lisa A; Huba,
G. J; Brown, Vivian B; Slaughter, Ruth. (1999). Evaluation of the effects
of outreach to women with multiple vulnerabilities on entry into substance
abuse treatment. Evaluation
& Program Planning. Vol 22(3), 269-277.
Investigated whether the
number of outreach contacts to substance abusing women predicts the likelihood
of their entry into drug abuse treatment and examined the relationships
among readiness to seek assistance, the women's level of involvement with
the outreach project, and admission to treatment. 665 women (aged 16-74
yrs) who participated in an enhanced outreach and treatment readiness preparation
program were tracked to examine patterns of referral and entry into substance
abuse treatment. The number of outreach contacts was inversely related
to receiving referrals to substance abuse treatment, as well as to the
completion of those referrals (for a subsample of 551 women who had received
referrals). Victims of domestic violence were 50% more likely to receive
a referral to drug abuse treatment, but of the women who received such
a referral, the lack of involvement in a violent relationship predicted
entry into treatment. Findings are discussed in terms of their implications
for designing and implementing outreach and treatment programs for women
with multiple therapeutic issues, particularly substance abuse and domestic
violence.
Amaro, Hortensia; Nieves,
Rita; Johannes, Sergut Wolde; Cabeza, Nirzka M. Labault. (1999). Substance
abuse treatment: Critical issues and challenges in the treatment of Latina
women.Hispanic Journal of Behavioral
Sciences. Vol 21(3), 266-282.
Described the history of
childhood abuse (emotional, physical, and sexual), mental health problems,
and medical problems of 66 Latinas 18-35+ yr old, enrolled in a residential
substance abuse treatment program. Data were gathered through interviews
conducted at program entry. A significant majority reported a childhood
history of abuse (80%) and past year diagnosis of mental health problems
(76%) and health (68%) problems. Compared to those with no reported history
of childhood abuse, women with a history of abuse were more likely to be
predominantly Spanish speakers, report significantly higher levels of health
problems, have had children removed from their custody, and drop out in
the early stages of treatment. These findings have important implications
for the course of treatment, how history of abuse is handled in residential
treatment, and support services needed by clients.
Palacios, Wilson R; Urmann,
Catherine F; Newel, Richard; Hamilton, Nancy. (1999). Developing a sociological
framework for dually diagnosed women. Journal
of Substance Abuse Treatment. Vol 17(1-2), 91-102.
Studied social stressors
and the incidence of a comorbid diagnosis among women in a residential
therapeutic community for substance abuse treatment. Women were assessed
at the beginning of treatment and 6 mo after leaving the program. Baseline
assessments were completed for 143 18-37 yr old women. Clinically significant
scores on measures of antisocial and borderline personality were noted
for 116 women, 68 of whom completed 6-mo posttreatment assessments. Assessments
noted history of abuse, delinquent or criminal behavior, arrests, and number
of drugs used. Outcome variables were whether patients were arrest-free,
drug-free, and reunited with children. Women with histories of delinquent
and/or criminal behavior were more likely to have used more types of drugs
and multiple drugs. These women also tended to have a history of being
abused emotionally (57.1%), physically (48.9%), or sexually (39.7%). This
group was also less successful on all outcome measures at the 6-mo follow-up.
These results are consistent with research that indicates abuse plays a
central role in the development and chronic effect of personality disorders
and, in particular, posttraumatic stress disorder.
Harm, Nancy J; Thompson,
Patricia J; Chambers, Helen. (1998). The effectiveness of parent education
for substance abusing women offenders. Alcoholism
Treatment Quarterly. Vol 16(3), 63-77.
Evaluated a 15-wk parent
education program in a state prison for 104 women in which 63% of the participants
reported high use of drugs and/or alcohol. The Hudson's Index of Self-Esteem
(W. W. Hudson, 1982) and Bavolek's Adult-Adolescent Parenting Inventory
(S. J. Bavolek, 1984) were completed by the Ss before and after the program.
Data was also collected on families of origin, childhood abuse, domestic
violence, drug and alcohol use, mental and physical health histories, employment,
information about children, and parenting history. At the end of the program,
Ss were interviewed about their perceptions of the efficacy of the program,
the teaching methods employed, the skills of the teachers, and the value
of the classes to them personally. The authors found no difference in the
measures used between alcohol and drug-abusing women and the other participants.
However, the presence of a history of personal victimization, reported
by a high percentage of substance abusers, did influence scores.
Hien, Denise; Hien, Nina
M. (1998). Women, violence with intimates and substance abuse: Relevant
theory, empirical findings, and recommendations for future research. American
Journal of Drug & Alcohol Abuse. Vol 24(3), 419-438.
Evidence from the domains
of anthropology, criminology, psychology, and sociology indicates that
women are involved in many of the same acts of aggression and violence
as men, and that substance use may play an important role in these acts.
However, little is known of the pathways between violence and drug for
women. The authors review and integrate existing literature addressing
female violence and substance abuse, presenting available epidemiology,
theories, and research applicable to the study of this problem. They also
examine the political and methodological obstacles to conducting systematic
research on female aggressiveness and offer recommendations for future
epidemiological, preventive, and therapeutic research efforts in area.
Brewer, Devon D; Fleming,
Charles B; Haggerty, Kevin P; Catalano, Richard F. (1998). Drug use predictors
of partner violence in opiate dependent women. Violence
& Victims. Vol 13(2), 107-115.
Examined the use of specific
drugs as longitudinal predictors of violence between domestic partners
in a sample of 82 women in methadone treatment for opiate addiction. Crack
cocaine use, use of other forms of cocaine, and tranquilizer use were each
modestly to moderately positively associated with partner violence victimization.
Women who were heavy users of these drugs were more likely to be hit, slapped,
or shoved by their partners than light users or nonusers of these drugs.
In addition, women who had been using opiates for a shorter time and were
older when they began using were more likely to be victimized than those
who had been using them a longer time and were younger when they began
using, respectively. A similar pattern of relationships held for predictors
of partner violence perpetration, but the associations were smaller than
those for victimizations. Three possible expla- nations of these associations
are considered.
Murphy, Bridget S; Stevens,
Sally J; McGrath, Robin A; Wexler, Harry K; Reardon, Deborah. (1998). Women
and violence: A different look. Drugs
& Society. Vol 13(1-2), 131-144.
Examines the role (i.e.,
perpetrator vs. victim) that drug using women assume in different episodes
and/or settings of violence, and with whom these violent encounters occur.
It is hypothesized that women would be the perpetrator of violence against
sibling(s), sex partner(s), and their children (i.e., in a "home setting"
in which they might feel more power and/or control). Moreover, it is thought
that while women would frequently report being a victim of violence from
family member(s), many women would also report being the victim of violence
from a stranger. The self reported life experience of violent encounters
of 98 women (mean age 30.7 yrs) enrolled in a residential drug treatment
center in Tucson, Arizona is described. Results of the study indicate that
many of the women were both the perpetrators and victims of violence. Additionally,
the results indicate that aggressive acts from or against others may, in
part, be related to the amount of power or control that women had in the
relationship as well as the setting in which the violence occurred.
Clark, Alicia Hilton.Testing
a self-medication hypothesis in battered women. Dissertation
Abstracts International: Section B: the Sciences & Engineering. Vol
57(10-B), 6562, US: Univ. Microfilms International.Self-medication
provides a compelling explanation of motive for a woman to overuse and
become dependent on alcohol and drugs, especially given intense stress
symptoms that are characteristically manifested in response to chronic
and traumatic victimization, such as childhood abuse and/or spousal battering.
This study sampled 78 battered women, using validated pen and paper instruments
to measure the variables of substance abuse, severity of battering, childhood
physical and sexual abuse, and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Significant
correlations were found between severity of battering and victim alcohol
abuse and between childhood sexual abuse and victim alcohol abuse, supporting
a self-medication model. Multiple regressions yielded childhood sexual
abuse as the strongest predictor of victim alcohol abuse, when parental
substance abuse was statistically controlled.
Lisek, Victor Joseph.
(1996). Family of origin characteristics and personality disorders/tendencies
of type 1 male, type 2 male and female alcoholics. Dissertation
Abstracts International, A (Humanities and Social Sciences). Vol 56(8-A),
3004.
The study investigates the
relationship of family of origin characteristics and personality disorders
on three subgroups of alcoholics: type 1 male, type 2 male and female.
Data were retrieved from medical charts of 204 patients (51 females, 99
type 1 males and 54 type 2 males) who were diagnosed alcoholic and admitted
to an inpatient treatment program. Nineteen family of origin characteristics
were extracted from each patient's social and family history. Mean scores
of thirteen DSM-II-R personality disorders from the Millon Clinical Multiaxial
Inventory were used. Analysis of the data gave a descriptive statistic
profile of each subgroup. Family of origin characteristics of each subgroup
were analyzed using chi-square. T-test analyses were used to compare male
and female subgroups and type 1 male and type 2 male alcoholics. Parental
and familial alcoholism and childhood abuse were common patterns in all
of the subgroups. Findings also indicated high antisocial, aggressive and
narcissistic personality scores for males and high dependent, self-defeating
and borderline personality scores for females. Type 1 males had high compulsive
personality disorder scores and type 2 males had high histrionic scores.
Seven of nineteen family of origin characteristics and seven of thirteen
personality disorders showed a significant relationship with alcoholics.
Differences were higher between men and women than between type 1 and type
2 male alcoholics.
Miller, Brenda A; Downs,
William R. (1995). Violent victimization among women with alcohol problems.
Galanter, Marc (Ed). Recent developments
in alcoholism, Vol. 12: Alcoholism and women. (pp. 81-101). New
York, NY, US: Plenum Press.
(from the chapter) review
existing studies that suggest a significant and important link between
childhood victimization [particularly childhood sexual abuse] and the later
development of women's alcohol problems / a brief review of methodological
issues is provided for assessing the empirical evidence to date / explanations
for how and why these events are linked provide a framework for understanding
how intervention and prevention programs might benefit from this knowledge
/ the importance of this work for policy, planning, delivery of treatment,
prevention, and future research is discussed
Miller, Brenda A; Downs,
William R. (1993). The impact of family violence on the use of alcohol
by women. Alcohol Health
& Research World. Vol 17(2), 137-143.
Examined the relationship
between violence and alcohol problems in women. Interviews were conducted
with 472 women (aged 18-45 yrs) from 5 sources: outpatient alcoholism treatment
programs (OATPs), drinking and driving classes (DDCs), shelters and support
groups for women who have experienced partner violence, outpatient mental
health centers, and randomly selected households. OATP Ss experienced higher
rates of childhood victimization, significantly more severe violence by
fathers, and more childhood sexual abuse than did DDC Ss and women in households.
OATP Ss also experienced significantly more childhood sexual abuse than
did Ss without alcohol problems in other treatment settings and significantly
higher levels of violence by partners than Ss in the household sample.
Miller, Brenda A; Downs,
William R; Testa, Maria. (1993). Interrelationships between victimization
experiences and women's alcohol use. Journal
of Studies on Alcohol. Suppl 11, 109-117.
Explored the interrelationships
between experiences of childhood victimization and the development of women's
alcohol-related problems for 472 women (aged 18-45 yrs). Two different
forms of childhood victimization were examined: parent-to-child violence
and childhood sexual abuse (familial and nonfamilial). High rates of childhood
victimization for women with alcohol problems suggest that there is a link
between victimization and the development, specifically, of women's alcohol
problems. The rates of childhood victimization were significantly greater
for Ss with alcohol problems in treatment as compared to Ss without alcohol
problems in treatment. Even when holding the treatment condition and family
background variables constant, childhood victimization had a specific connection
to the development of women's alcohol problems.
Parisi-Dunne, Darlene.
(1992). Chemically dependent battered women: Some women's reality.
Dissertation Abstracts
International. Vol 52(10-A), 3726
Bayatpour, Mahin; Wells,
Robert D; Holford, Susan. (). Physical and sexual abuse as predictors of
substance use and suicide among pregnant teenagers. Journal
of Adolescent Health. Vol 13(2), 128-132.
In order to better define
risk factors for perinatal substance abuse, data from 352 pregnant adolescents
(aged 12-19 yrs) enrolled in a comprehensive prenatal clinic were analyzed.
Following an interview, all Ss were given a complete prenatal examination,
including drug toxicology screening. Self-reported rates of substance use
before awareness of conception varied from 23% for tobacco to 17% for alcohol
and marijuana; 7% of the Ss reported use of illicit substances (e.g., cocaine)
after conception was confirmed. 80 Ss acknowledged having been physically
or sexually abused, and 40 admitted to having suicidal ideation or actions.
A comparison of those Ss who had been physically or sexually abused with
the remaining cohort revealed significant differences on marijuana and
cocaine use prior to awareness of conception and on prior suicidality.
Ladwig, Gail B; Andersen,
Marcia D. (). Substance abuse in women: Relationship between chemical dependency
of women and past reports of physical and/or sexual abuse.
Sampselle, Carolyn M.
(Ed). (1992). Violence against women: Nursing research, education, and
practice issues. Series in
health care for women. (pp. 167-180). Washington, DC, US: Hemisphere
Publishing Corp.
(from the chapter) look
at the histories of female incarcerated felons who are chemically dependent
or who are chemically dependent prior to their conviction / in reviewing
the histories, we looked for self-reporting of past family violence and/or
sexual abuse / we are not suggesting cause and effect but are reporting
on a possible association literature review [incest, sexual and family
violence; boundary inadequacy; specific concerns of women; assessment needs]
/ conceptual framework / intervention model / research design and methodology
Swett, Chester; Cohen,
Caryn; Surrey, Janet; Compaine, Andrew; et al. (1991). High rates of alcohol
use and history of physical and sexual abuse among women outpatients. AmericanJournal
of Drug & Alcohol Abuse. Vol 17(1), 49-60.
Surveyed 189 new female
patients at an adult psychiatric outpatient clinic that did not have a
specific alcoholic treatment program. 27 Ss reported a history of heavy
alcohol consumption measured by scores of 10 or more on the Michigan Alcoholism
Screening Test (MAST), but only 16 had a diagnosis of alcohol abuse or
alcohol dependence made by a clinician. Ss with a self-reported history
of physical and/or sexual abuse had significantly higher MAST scores than
Ss with no such history. When the 1st abuse occurred before age 18 yrs
and there was no recent reported abuse, the association of abuse and high
MAST scores persisted. This suggests that early physical or sexual abuse
may be associated with current levels of alcohol use.
Woodhouse, Lynn D. (1990).
An exploratory study of the use of life history methods to determine treatment
needs for female substance abusers. Response
to the Victimization of Women & Children. Vol 13(3), 12-15. Studied
25 women (aged 18-32 yrs) in a substance abuse treatment program, using
life history methods. Most Ss had experienced psychic pain for many years
from bottled-up fear and anger, self-hate, and neglect. The most prominent
theme was that of violence and abuse. More than half the Ss reported that
they had been raped or had been the victim of incest, child abuse, or domestic
violence. Other themes included male dominance; heavy dependence on men
for money, drugs, and sex; motherhood and parenting; neglect; depression;
guilt; sexuality and the possibility of having acquired immune deficiency
syndrome (AIDS); and use of material possessions to define worth. It is
suggested that treatment for female substance abusers should draw on a
full range of community agencies. A gender-specific treatment program is
outlined.
Beeman, Sandra K; Hagemeister,
Annelies K; Edleson, Jeffrey L. (2001). Case assessment and service receipt
in families experiencing both child maltreatment and woman battering.Journal
of Interpersonal Violence. Vol 16(5) May 2001, 437-458.
Notes that professional
attention to families experiencing both child maltreatment and woman battering
has increased in recent years. This study examined data for 172 families--95
families for which police had filed child abuse incident reports and adult
domestic assault incident reports, and 77 other families for which police
had filed child maltreatment reports but had no documentation of domestic
assaults. Exploring differences between the 2 groups of families, the authors
found that dual-violence families were more likely to include an unrelated
male in the household, to involve a neglect allegation, and to include
perpetrator substance abuse. Child protection workers assessed dual-violence
families to be at higher risk and were more likely to open the case for
child protection services. Among open cases, however, dual-violence families
received fewer services but were more likely to be referred to the county
attorney. These findings and their implications for policy, practice, and
research are discussed.
McCloskey, Laura Ann.
(2001). The "Medea complex" among men: The instrumental abuse of children
to injure wives. Violence
& Victims. Vol 16(1), 19-37.
It has been previously documented
that wife and child abuse often co-occur. The present study tested competing
hypotheses about the reasons for this co-occurrence, specifically trait
versus instrumental theories of aggression within families. Three commonly
cited catalysts (unemployment, drinking, and life stress events) for men's
abuse of family members were analyzed to determine whether they equally
predict partner or child abuse. Interviews were conducted with 363 women
and children about spousal and paternal abuse, and women were interviewed
about sociodemographcis and the stressors described above. Families were
oversampled for the presence of spousal violence. Logistic regressions
revealed that heavy drinking and life stress events predicted men's abuse
of their partners. These risk factors were unrelated to child abuse. Wife
battering, however, placed children at heightened risk. Children of battered
women stood a 42% chance of receiving escalated abuse from their fathers.
It is proposed that men's abuse of children is in many instances instrumental
in order to coerce or retaliate against women, echoing the Greek myth of
Medea who killed her own children to spite their father.
Malpique, Celeste; Barrias,
Paula; Morais, Luisa; Salgado, Monica; Pinta da Costa, Isabel; Rodriques,
Marta. (1998). Violence and alcoholism in the family: How are the children
affected? Alcohol & Alcoholism.
Vol 33(1), 42-46.
Evaluated the effects of
an alcohol-associated violent family environment on children and adolescents
in such a family. Specifically, this study examined the offspring's mental
representation of their father, the effects of the model of the marital
relationship that was presented to them, and their psychological well-being,
including feelings of insecurity, dependence and depression. Interviews
were conducted with the members of 20 families with known violence associated
with alcohol problems and the children and adolescents completed psychological
tests, including the Corman Family Drawing test and the Patte Noire test.
Results show the existence of psychopathological disturbances in these
children, whose immaturity and insecurity were expressed by aggressive
behavior or by depressive manifestations. Also found was a transgenerational
alcoholism-violence frequency.
GAY, LESBIAN, BISEXUAL, TRANSGENDERED
Cruz, J. Michael; Peralta,
Robert L. (2001). Family violence and substance use: The perceived effects
of substance use within gay male relationships. Violence
& Victims. Vol 16(2), 161-172.
Examined the life situations
of gay men where domestic violence was present. This article expands on
previously published works by examining respondents' perceptions of what
role alcohol and other drug use plays in causing substance use-related
domestic violence. In-depth interviews were conducted with 25 gay males
(aged 23-43 yrs). Three different perceptions emerged from the data and
are presented here. First, drugs and alcohol use were perceived to be causally
related to the domestic violence the respondents endured. Second, respondents
believed substance abuse resulted from the violence--it was used as a coping
mechanism. Finally, many respondents did not believe there was any association
between substance abuse and violence. The need for further in-depth data
related to the relationship between drugs, alcohol, and domestic violence
is noted.
Neisen, Joseph H; Sandall,
Hilary. (1990). Alcohol and other drug abuse in a gay/lesbian population:
Related to victimization? Journal
of Psychology & Human Sexuality. Vol 3(1), 151-168.
Studied the prevalence of
sexual abuse in recovering chemically dependent lesbians and gay men. A
retrospective chart review of 201 inpatients (aged 20-39 yrs) showed that
nearly 50% reported being sexually abused in childhood. These data are
placed in the context of long-term effects of childhood sexual abuse. Chemical
dependency treatment programs must recognize and support their clients'
need to address sexual abuse to prevent relapse and to improve general
emotional well-being. However, most treatment centers are reluctant to
address sexuality and related problems.
Schilit, Rebecca; Lie,
Gwat-yong; Montagne, Marilyn. (1990). Substance use as a correlate of violence
in intimate lesbian relationships. Journal
of Homosexuality. Vol 19(3), 51-65.
Examined the problem of
domestic violence as related to substance abuse in lesbian relationships
by surveying 104 self-identified lesbians (aged 22-52 yrs). Of the 39 Ss
who reported a past or present abusive relationship, 64% reported alcohol
or drugs were involved before or during incidents of battering. Ss' frequency
of drinking significantly correlated with committing abusive acts as well
as with being the victim of abusive acts.